Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

Part of our topic study: Early Christian Beliefs About Hell

Early church questionHell

How can hell be both fire and outer darkness?

Download PDFPrint-ready for Bible study or church

Large type, the short answer first, and every passage listed at the back.

All 422 early church questions

Compiled by machine learning · Sources checked

Early Christian and biblical answers, compiled by machine learning from The Historic Faith's library of early-Christian writings and the Bible. Every quotation was matched word for word to our text and links to the full passage. The match checks our stored text, not every interpretation or who wrote each work. How we make these pages

Not yet reviewed by The Historic Faith. We may correct, decline or remove this page.

The short answer

Interpretation

The early writers did not see a conflict. They spoke of fire and darkness together. Fire is God's punishment, and darkness is the loss of God's light, which the wicked chose to flee. They also taught that the divine fire is not like the ordinary fire we use, so it need not behave like it.

Interpretation: our reading of the passages, not their words.

Read the key passageAgainst Heresies: Book IV (opens in a new tab)

27 passages from 13 writers on this page; 10 quotations from 6 of them in the key points — a starting point, not a full survey.

Key points, with the passages under each

Our notes, compiled by machine learning, each followed by the writer's exact words and a link to the full passage. From the text = says what the passage says. Interpretation = our reading of the passages, not their words.

  1. Point 1: Fire and darkness are named together

    Our note · compiled by machine learningFrom the text

    Lactantius describes the coming judgment with both images at once. He speaks of fire and darkness in the black night. Later he says the wicked will be hidden in darkness and kept for punishment. He does not treat the two as a contradiction.

    When He comes, there will be fire and darkness in the middle of the black night.

    Lactantius c. 290–320 AD Divine Institutes 19 Source 1 THF's updated English

    Instead, they will be hidden in the same darkness with the wicked, appointed for certain punishment.

    Lactantius c. 290–320 AD Divine Institutes 21 Source 2 THF's updated English
  2. Point 2: The lake of fire is eternal fire

    Our note · compiled by machine learningFrom the text

    Irenaeus follows Revelation, where death and hell are thrown into the lake of fire. He says this is the same as Gehenna, the eternal fire the Lord spoke of. Tatian's Gospel harmony records the Lord's words sending the cursed into that eternal fire.

    This is what is called Gehenna, which the Lord referred to as eternal fire.

    Irenaeus c. 175–202 AD Against Heresies: Book V · Source 3 THF's updated English

    Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his hosts.

    Tatian c. 150–180 AD Diatessaron 43 Source 4 THF's updated English
  3. Point 3: Darkness fits those who flee the light

    Our note · compiled by machine learningFrom the text

    Irenaeus explains the darkness by what people choose. God gives light to those who seek it. Those who turn away from His light blind themselves, and God gives them the darkness that matches their choice. The darkness is a fitting result, not a random punishment.

    He generously provides the light that those who seek the light of incorruption desire; but for those who despise and mock, avoiding and turning away from this light, effectively blinding themselves, He has prepared darkness appropriate for those who oppose light, and delivered a fitting punishment upon those who try to avoid submission to Him.

    later in the same passage

    Those who avoid rest will rightfully face punishment, and those who shun light will rightfully dwell in darkness.

    Irenaeus c. 175–202 AD Against Heresies: Book IV · Source 5 THF's updated English
  4. Point 4: Darkness means losing every good thing

    Our note · compiled by machine learningFrom the text

    Irenaeus compares this to sunlight. People who hide from the light put themselves in the dark, and the light is not to blame. In the same way, those who flee God's eternal light live in eternal darkness, without any of the good things found in God.

    Similarly, those who flee the eternal light of God, which contains all good things, become the cause for themselves of living in eternal darkness, lacking all good things, having made themselves the cause of their existence in such an abode.

    Irenaeus c. 175–202 AD Against Heresies: Book IV · Source 5 THF's updated English
  5. Point 5: Origen saw darkness as deep ignorance

    Our note · compiled by machine learningInterpretation

    Origen offers his own view carefully. He thinks outer darkness may mean less a dark place and more a state of deep ignorance, cut off from the light of understanding. He even suggests the wicked may be clothed with dark bodies that show this inner darkness.

    But the outer darkness, in my judgment, is to be understood not so much as some dark atmosphere without any light, but as those persons who, having been plunged into the darkness of profound ignorance, have been placed beyond the reach of any light of the understanding.

    Origen c. 215–254 AD De Principiis (On First Principles) 10 Source 6 THF's updated English
Show 1 more point
  1. Point 6: The divine fire is unlike ordinary fire

    Our note · compiled by machine learningInterpretation

    Lactantius says the divine fire burns the wicked and also restores what it burns, so it feeds itself forever. It even draws back from the righteous. A fire like this does not act the way our fires do, so we should not expect it to follow the rules of an earthly flame.

    Therefore, the same divine fire, with one and the same force and power, will both burn the wicked and form them again. It will restore as much of their bodies as it consumes, and it will keep feeding itself forever.

    later in the same passage

    So great is the power of innocence that the flame draws back from it without causing harm.

    Lactantius c. 290–320 AD Divine Institutes 21 Source 2 THF's updated English

What these passages don't tell us

  • These passages do not explain hell's fire by kinds of earthly flame, such as fires that give little light.
  • Origen's reading of outer darkness is offered as his own opinion, not as the settled teaching of the church.
  • A word-for-word match shows that a quotation really is in our text. It does not show that our reading of it is right, or who wrote each work.

27 passages from 13 writers on this page; 10 quotations from 6 of them in the key points — a starting point, not a full survey.

The whole body of evidence

Everything the early writers said on this

All 27 passages from 13 writers, sorted under the point each one supports, then the rest by writer. The 6 quoted in full above are listed by name. Every link opens the full passage in a new tab.

  • 27 passages
  • 13 writers
  • 33 Bible verses
  • 1st–4th century

The chat’s search returned 159 hits. 37 were repeats of the same paragraphs. 3 could not be matched word for word to our text, so they are not shown. We left out 92 that do not answer it: weak matches that share almost no words with the question (24), the key word used in another sense (29), short fragments with no subject (5) and other subjects (34). Nothing was added by hand.

“Quotation marks” = the writer’s exact words. Excerpt = the opening lines of a longer passage, cut with “…”. 1885 English = the Roberts–Donaldson translation (public domain); THF’s updated English = our modern wording. Passages are in THF’s updated English and the 1885 Roberts–Donaldson translation, labelled on each passage.

Who said what, writer by writer

13 writers
Early writers on this question: when they wrote, how many passages, which points, and one line in their words
WriterOn this pageOne line from themTheir passages
Clement of Romec. 88–99 AD1 passagePoint 2“their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched …”See it from Clement of Rome
Justin Martyrc. 130–165 AD4 passagesPoint 2 Also on this question“they, having been shut up in eternal fire …”See all 4 from Justin Martyr
Minucius Felixc. 150–270 AD1 passagePoint 6“the fires of Mount Ætna and of Mount Vesuvius …”See it from Minucius Felix
Tatianc. 150–180 AD3 passagesPoint 2 Also on this question“into life crippled or maimed than to have two hands or two feet and be thrown into the …”See all 3 from Tatian
Irenaeusc. 175–202 AD5 passagesPoint 2 Point 3 Point 4 Also on this question“in the other, really, enduringly, and more rigidly: for the fire is eternal …”See all 5 from Irenaeus
Clement of Alexandriac. 190–215 AD2 passagesAlso on this question“the useless servant shall be cast into outer darkness …”See all 2 from Clement of Alexandria
Hippolytusc. 200–236 AD2 passagesPoint 2 Also on this question“their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched …”See all 2 from Hippolytus
Origenc. 215–254 AD2 passagesPoint 5 Point 6“But the outer darkness, in my judgment, is to be understood not …”See all 2 from Origen
Cyprianc. 248–258 AD2 passagesPoint 2“to believe here, and then they will be unable to return so that they may believe. An ever-burning …”See all 2 from Cyprian
Commodianusc. 250–300 AD1 passagePoint 2“the flame of fire the Lord will judge the wicked …”See it from Commodianus
Methodiusc. 270–311 AD1 passagePoint 6as will be forever undecaying and indissoluble. For I once saw on Olympus …See it from Methodius
Lactantiusc. 290–320 AD2 passagesPoint 1 Point 6“the same divine fire, with one and the same force and power …”See all 2 from Lactantius
Peter of Alexandriac. 300–311 AD1 passagePoint 6as will be forever undecaying and indissoluble. For I once saw on Olympus …See it from Peter of Alexandria

Oldest first, by our catalog’s dates. Lines in quotation marks are the writer’s exact words; lines without them are the opening of a longer passage.

Point 1: no passages beyond the ones quoted above.

Point 2

The lake of fire is eternal fire

12 passages: 2 quoted above, 10 more here

Back to our note on point 2

Show 9 more on point 2Show fewer
Show 4 more on point 2Show fewer

Points 3, 4 and 5: no passages beyond the ones quoted above.

Point 6

The divine fire is unlike ordinary fire

5 passages: 1 quoted above, 4 more here

Back to our note on point 6

Show 2 more on point 6Show fewer

The rest

Also on this question

7 passages that bear on the question without sitting under one point, by writer, oldest first.

Justin Martyrc. 130–165 AD · 1 passage

Tatianc. 150–180 AD · 1 passage

Irenaeusc. 175–202 AD · 2 passages

Clement of Alexandriac. 190–215 AD · 2 passages

Hippolytusc. 200–236 AD · 1 passage

Scripture behind the passages

Every Bible verse on this question

33 verses in 14 books, in Bible order: the verses the chat found, the verses the writers cite, and the verses THF links to their passages. The wording is The Faith Once Delivered Bible, our own translation, still in progress: the New Testament, and the Old Testament from the Greek Septuagint the early church read. Where the Septuagint numbers a verse differently, its tag shows the Septuagint number. Each link opens the verse in our audio Bible, in a new tab. 85 more verses linked by THF to these passages are listed by reference in All sources on this page.

“Cited by” means the 1885 edition prints the verse in a footnote to that passage. “Linked by THF” is a THF verse link, partly machine-linked: the verse is related to the passage, not always quoted in it. A verse with neither line was found by the chat’s search for this question.

Matthew · 8 verses

Show 25 more versesShow fewer

Mark · 5 verses

Luke · 1 verse

John · 2 verses

Acts · 2 verses

Romans · 1 verse

Galatians · 1 verse

Ephesians · 1 verse

Colossians · 1 verse

2 Thessalonians · 2 verses

Hebrews · 2 verses

2 Peter · 1 verse

Jude · 1 verse

Revelation · 5 verses

Check it yourself

The original language and where to read further. Every passage and verse is listed in All sources on this page, at the bottom.

Original language

not available

This page shows THF's updated English and the 1885 Roberts–Donaldson translation, labelled on each passage. Open a passage in our library to see what we hold for it.

Further research

1 related passage

Related passages the study found. They are not the answer to this question.

  • Exegetical Fragments 1From the text

    Hippolytus: Hippolytus warns that obeying men rather than God brings eternal punishment.

Keep studying

How this page was made

computer checks only
  • Compiled byMachine learning, on THF's own key. It used only passages from THF's library.
  • Quotations10 of 10 match our stored text word for word.
  • Links tested6 of 6 passage links open the exact paragraph, and the quote is on that page.
  • Writers4 — Lactantius, Irenaeus, Tatian, Origen. Names and dates are our catalog's.
  • TranslationTHF's updated English. The full list of passages uses THF's updated English and the 1885 Roberts–Donaldson translation, labelled on each passage.
  • Listen6 of the 6 key-point passages narrated by a computer narrator.
  • Full list27 passages and 118 Bible verses, each linked. The chat’s search returned 159 hits; 92 not about this question were left out.
  • Original languageNone on file for these passages.
  • Person's reviewNot yet.
  • Not checkedThe interpretation. Who wrote each work. Whether other passages say more.

How to cite this page

“How can hell be both fire and outer darkness?” The Historic Faith, published 9 Nov 2026. https://thehistoricfaith.com/early-church-questions/how-can-hell-be-both-fire-and-outer-darkness

All sources on this page

27 passages · 118 verses

Every passage and Bible verse this page draws on, each linked to where it is. Links open in a new tab.

Passages, by writer 27

Clement of Rome c. 88–99 AD · 1

  1. Second Epistle 17 (opens in a new tab)Point 2“their worm shall not die, neither shall…”

Justin Martyr c. 130–165 AD · 4

  1. Dialogue with Trypho (opens in a new tab)and Jacob, in the kingdom of heaven:…
  2. Dialogue with Trypho (opens in a new tab)Point 2we know from Isaiah that the bodies…
  3. Second Apology (opens in a new tab)Point 2“they, having been shut up in eternal…”
  4. First Apology (opens in a new tab)Point 2“we believe that those who live wickedly…”

Minucius Felix c. 150–270 AD · 1

  1. Octavius 24 (opens in a new tab)Point 6“the fires of Mount Ætna and of…”

Tatian c. 150–180 AD · 3

  1. Diatessaron 25 (opens in a new tab)Point 2“into life crippled or maimed than to…”
  2. Diatessaron 43 (opens in a new tab)“25:30 And the unprofitable servant, put him…”
  3. Diatessaron 43 (opens in a new tab)Point 2“Depart from me, you cursed, into the…”

Irenaeus c. 175–202 AD · 5

  1. Against Heresies: Book IV (opens in a new tab)who haven’t received the Holy Spirit due…
  2. Against Heresies: Book IV (opens in a new tab)Points 3, 4“He generously provides the light that those…”
  3. Against Heresies: Book V (opens in a new tab)Point 2“This is what is called Gehenna, which…”
  4. Against Heresies: Book IV (opens in a new tab)“the children of the kingdom shall go…”
  5. Against Heresies: Book IV (opens in a new tab)Point 2“in the other, really, enduringly, and more…”

Clement of Alexandria c. 190–215 AD · 2

  1. Stromata 1.1 (opens in a new tab)“the useless servant shall be cast into…”
  2. Instructor 1.10 (opens in a new tab)“also that was said, They that fall…”

Hippolytus c. 200–236 AD · 2

  1. Treatise on Christ and Antichrist 1 (opens in a new tab)Point 2“their worm shall not die, neither shall…”
  2. Against Plato 1 (opens in a new tab)“sleep will give them rest. No night…”

Origen c. 215–254 AD · 2

  1. De Principiis (On First Principles) 10 (opens in a new tab)Point 5“But the outer darkness, in my judgment,…”
  2. De Principiis (On First Principles) 10 (opens in a new tab)Point 6“he says, "Walk in the light of…”

Cyprian c. 248–258 AD · 2

  1. Treatises (opens in a new tab)Point 2“to believe here, and then they will…”
  2. Epistles (opens in a new tab)Point 2His divine knowledge. Then He will send…

Commodianus c. 250–300 AD · 1

  1. Writings (opens in a new tab)Point 2“the flame of fire the Lord will…”

Methodius c. 270–311 AD · 1

  1. From the Discourse on the Resurrection (opens in a new tab)Point 6as will be forever undecaying and indissoluble.…

Lactantius c. 290–320 AD · 2

  1. Divine Institutes 21 (opens in a new tab)Points 1, 6“Instead, they will be hidden in the…”
  2. Divine Institutes 19 (opens in a new tab)Point 1“When He comes, there will be fire…”

Peter of Alexandria c. 300–311 AD · 1

  1. Genuine Acts of Peter (opens in a new tab)Point 6as will be forever undecaying and indissoluble.…

Bible verses 33

Also linked by THF to these passages 85

Partly machine-linked: related to the passages, not always quoted in them.

Searched: Ante-Nicene Fathers volumes 1–9 and the Bible, including the Septuagint.

See something wrong?

Wrong quote, broken link or a privacy worry? Tell us and we will look at it.

Report a problem with this page

Have your own question? Members can ask the Early Christian Chat.

© 2026 The Historic Faith. Selection, arrangement and editing by THF; machine-compiled text and public-domain quotations are not claimed. Free for personal study; please don't republish. Terms