Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 4
The chapter contrasts our modern expectation of rapid change with ancient societyโ€™s tendency to preserve ancestral ways; how might modern Christians misread early church history because we assume people then were as change-oriented as we are now?
Another way to ask: The chapter says modern people expect fast change, but ancient people usually kept the ways of their ancestors. How might modern Christians misunderstand early church history if we assume ancient people liked change as much as we do?

Direct Answer

Modern Christians may wrongly assume that early Christians would have changed doctrines and practices as rapidly and easily as modern societies do. Bercot argues that this projects a modern expectation of change onto ancient people, who were generally much more committed to preserving ancestral ways.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot says, โ€œToday we live in a fast-changing society, a society where change is expected.โ€ - He adds that โ€œchange is usually welcome today,โ€ but calls this โ€œa new phenomenon in human history.โ€ - He claims, โ€œOur society has changed more in the past 250 years than it did in the previous 4,000 years.โ€ - Before the Industrial Revolution and political revolutions of the 1700s, people โ€œstrongly believed in doing things the way their ancestors did them.โ€ - He says we are โ€œso used to change todayโ€ that we find it hard to believe a society or Church could exist โ€œfor a century without change.โ€

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript suggests that modern assumptions can distort historical judgment. A fair reading of early church history should account for ancient conservatism, not only modern patterns of rapid innovation.