Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 4
Early Christians called abortion “murder” and grounded it in God’s care for the fetus as a “created being”; how does their reasoning challenge common modern Christian ways of arguing about abortion (politically, pragmatically, or by “hard cases”), and what does it reveal about how they believed God evaluates hidden, private sins?
Another way to ask: Early Christians called abortion “murder” because they believed God cares for the unborn child as His creation. How does that challenge the way Christians today often argue about abortion—through politics, what “works,” or hard cases—and what does it say about how God sees private sins?

Direct Answer Their reasoning is moral and God-centered rather than political or pragmatic: the fetus is “a created being” under God’s care, so abortion is “murder” even when done privately. That challenges arguments that lean mainly on public policy, convenience, or exceptions, because the early Christian focus is accountability to God for what happens “in the…bowels,” unseen by society.

Support from Transcript:

  • Mark Felix condemns abortion as murder: women “by drinking special potions…extinguish the life of the future human…thus committing murder before they even give birth.”
  • Athenagoras ties it to God’s view: the fetus is “a created being and therefore an object of God’s care,” and women who abort “will have to render an account to God.”
  • Tertullian: “we may not destroy even the fetus in the womb,” and “to hinder a birth is merely a speedier form of killing.”
  • The context shows abortion was “completely moral, civilized” in Rome, yet Christians opposed it anyway.
  • Bercot highlights that the sin is treated seriously even when done privately and socially approved.
Discussion Follow-ups How would the church’s tone and strategy change if our primary argument was “account to God” rather than winning a political fight? What does “object of God’s care” demand of Christians beyond voting?

Jumpstarter 4 of 10
Back Questions Next