Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Will The Real Heretics Please Stand Up  /  Chapter 17: The Quest to Restore Early Christianity  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 10
Bercot notes that after the Stone-Campbell merger the movement “focused more on primitive doctrine and ordinances than on holy living and the inner life,” and then highlights the Oxford movement making early Christian writings cheaply available to ordinary people; what dangers do you see in pursuing “restoration” primarily through correct structures and texts, and what concrete steps could your group take to pursue restoration that includes both inner transformation and visible holiness?
Another way to ask: What is the danger of trying to “restore” the church mostly by getting the right doctrines, texts, and church structures, and what steps could your group take to pursue both inner change and a holy lifestyle?

Direct Answer The transcript warns that restoration can become mainly about correct doctrine, ordinances, and access to early texts while neglecting “holy living” and “the inner life”; Bercot’s emphasis implies groups must pursue Spirit-empowered inner change that produces outward separation from the world.

Support from Transcript:

  • After the merger, the movement “focused more on primitive doctrine and ordinances than on holy living and the inner life,” naming the imbalance.
  • Earlier, Stone’s “chief objective” had been “holy living and separation from the world,” showing what got de-emphasized.
  • Bercot says Wesley realized “The Holy Spirit must radically change a person from the inside out,” and “There can be no return to primitive Christianity without the empowering work of the Holy Spirit.”
  • He adds that Spirit-filling “will necessarily be an outward change in his lifestyle… No one living in the Holy Spirit walks in the ways of the world.”
  • The Oxford movement made early writings available cheaply, so ordinary Christians “can discover for themselves what early Christianity was really like”—a benefit that could still remain only informational.
Discussion Follow-ups What practices in your group would intentionally connect learning (texts, history) to repentance and lifestyle change? How will you measure “restoration”—by correct forms, or by Spirit-produced holiness?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done