Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Romans Commentary Chapters 9-16  /  Romans 9:10-13 the Two Nations from Jacob and Esau Part One  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 1
David Bercot argues that Paul’s point in Romans 9 is that “not every fleshly Jew is automatically a child of Abraham,” using Esau as the “powerful example”; what does that claim reveal about how God views covenant identity, and what parts of modern Christian thinking about “being born into it” (Christian family, Christian nation, baptismal culture) does it unsettle?
Another way to ask: If Paul’s point is that not every Jew by birth is truly a child of Abraham, what does that say about who God counts as “in the covenant”? How does that challenge the idea that you’re automatically Christian because of your family, nation, or church culture?

Direct Answer Based on David Bercot’s teaching, covenant identity is not guaranteed by bloodline, outward covenant markers, or being born into the “right” group; God can include or exclude based on what kind of people they truly are. That unsettles any modern confidence that someone is automatically “in” simply because they were raised in a Christian setting or surrounded by Christian culture.

Support from Transcript:

  • Paul’s aim: “not every fleshly Jew is automatically a child of Abraham… Just because someone is an ethnic Jew does not necessarily mean he is part of the true Israel of God.”
  • Esau is “a particularly powerful example” because he was “a fleshly descendant of both Abraham and Isaac” and “born under the covenant of circumcision,” yet still “rejected.”
  • Bercot stresses: “That is how little a direct bloodline to Abraham means.”
  • He concludes: “If Esau could be excluded… obviously then any other descendant of Abraham and Isaac can be excluded as well.”
  • God “is free to choose whomever He wants… He is not bound to include people… simply because they are ethnic descendants of Abraham.”
Discussion Follow-ups What modern “automatic belonging” do we rely on most—family background, church identity, or national identity—and how would Romans 9 correct that confidence?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10
Back Questions Next