Continue through Romans chapters 9-16 with insights from early Christian interpreters. Study Paul's teaching on Israel, practical Christian living, and the outworking of the gospel in everyday life.

This course is free to access. The Historic Faith is donation-funded, with no paywall and no subscription required. Generous supporters help keep these lessons open to anyone in the world.

Course Content

Play Without Quiz Interruptions

Plays through this course continuously and skips quiz and discussion stops. On desktop, this opens the normal playlist player with your current place.

Free Audiobook Guide

What This Free Course Covers

This free course continues David Bercot’s commentary on Romans by walking through chapters 9–16 with special attention to how Romans was understood before Augustine and Luther. The lessons follow Paul’s argument about God’s mercy to Jews and Gentiles, the place of Israel, the inclusion of the Gentiles, and the difference between righteousness sought through the Mosaic Law and righteousness through faith in Christ. The course also traces Paul’s shift from argument to exhortation:

living as a sacrifice, using gifts humbly in one body, loving without hypocrisy, refusing retaliation, submitting to governing authorities, and respecting the consciences of fellow believers. Later lessons cover unity between Jewish and Gentile Christians, Paul’s ministry and travel plans, his greetings to believers in Rome, and his closing warning against divisive teachers.

Throughout the course, Bercot interacts with early Christian writers such as Origen, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Ambrosiaster, Chrysostom, and others where the transcripts present their comments.

Jews and Gentiles Mercy and responsibility Children of promise Faith and grace Mosaic Law fulfilled True Israel Transformed life Love fulfills the law Conscience and unity Warnings against division

What You Will Study

  • Romans 9 as Paul’s discussion of God’s mercy toward Jews and Gentiles, rather than an isolated proof text about arbitrary predestination
  • The meaning of true Israel, the children of promise, and the examples of Isaac, Jacob, Esau, Pharaoh, and the potter and clay
  • Paul’s teaching that Jews and Gentiles stand before God on equal terms through grace and faith in Jesus Christ
  • The early Christian distinction between the works of the Mosaic Law and obedient faith lived out after initial salvation
  • Romans 12–13 on the transformed Christian life, love, nonretaliation, government, and walking in the light
  • Romans 14–15 on food scruples, conscience, judging others, edification, unity, and Jewish-Gentile peace in the church
  • Paul’s ministry to the Gentiles, his planned journey to Rome, his collection for the poor in Jerusalem, and his final greetings
  • Romans 16 on faithful coworkers, women commended by Paul, household order, the holy kiss, and warnings against division

Questions This Course Helps Answer

  • Why does this course argue that Romans 9 should be read in the flow of Paul’s larger argument?
  • What does Paul mean when he says not all who are of Israel are truly Israel?
  • How are Isaac, Jacob, and Esau used to explain the children of promise?
  • How did early Christians respond to Gnostic and later predestinarian readings of Romans 9?
  • What does the hardening of Pharaoh mean in this commentary?
  • How does the potter and clay image relate to Israel, Gentiles, repentance, and responsibility?
  • Why does Paul say Christ is the end of the law?
  • How are faith, obedience, grace, and works of the Mosaic Law distinguished in these lessons?
  • What does Romans 12 teach about living as a sacrifice and being transformed?
  • Why does Paul command Christians not to repay evil for evil?
  • How does this course explain submission to governing authorities and the limits of obedience to Caesar?
  • How should Christians handle food scruples and matters of conscience without judging one another?

Lesson-by-Lesson Guide

Romans 9:1-5 Understanding God’s Mercy and Israel’s Role

This lesson introduces Romans 9 as part of Paul’s larger argument about God’s mercy to Jews and Gentiles. It also discusses Paul’s grief for Israel, the meaning of anathema, and early Christian testimony to Christ’s divinity in Romans 9:5.

  • Why should Romans 9 not be read in isolation?
  • How does Paul express his sorrow for Israel?
  • How did early Christians understand Paul’s statement about Christ as God over all?

Romans 9:6-9 the Children of the Flesh vs. the Children of Promise

This lesson explains Paul’s statement that not all who are of Israel are truly Israel. It contrasts fleshly descent from Abraham with the children of promise who follow Christ by faith.

  • What does it mean that not all Israel is Israel?
  • Why does Paul use Isaac as an example?
  • How are believers connected to Abraham’s promise?

Romans 9:10-13 the Two Nations from Jacob and Esau Part One

This lesson begins the discussion of Jacob and Esau as an argument about two peoples rather than isolated individual destinies. It presents Paul’s point that God could include Gentiles in His people before their spiritual birth, just as Jacob was chosen before birth.

  • Why does Paul move from Isaac to Jacob and Esau?
  • How does the lesson connect Jacob and Esau with two nations?
  • What does this passage say about Gentile inclusion?

Romans 9:10-13 the Two Nations from Jacob and Esau Part Two

This lesson continues the Jacob and Esau discussion by emphasizing fleshly Israel and spiritual Israel. It connects Paul’s argument in Romans with Old Testament prophecies about Gentiles coming to the God of Jacob and with Paul’s parallel use of Sarah and Hagar in Galatians.

  • How does the Jacob and Esau passage relate to fleshly and spiritual Israel?
  • Why does the lesson bring in Old Testament prophecies about the Gentiles?
  • How does Galatians 4 help explain Paul’s argument?

Romans 9:14-16 God Shows Mercy on Whom He Wills

This lesson explains Paul’s answer to the charge that God is unjust for showing mercy to the Gentiles. It applies the passage mainly to Jews and Gentiles while also discussing individual salvation, human response, obedience, and God’s greater role in salvation.

  • Why does Paul say there is no injustice with God?
  • How does the golden calf episode illuminate God’s mercy?
  • How does this lesson balance divine mercy and human response?

Romans 9:17-18 the Hardening of Pharaoh

This lesson discusses Pharaoh’s hardening and argues that God’s patience and actions can soften some people while hardening others who despise His kindness. It also applies the pattern to unbelieving Jews who hardened their own hearts while other Jews came to faith.

  • What is the difference between God raising Pharaoh up and creating Pharaoh for that purpose?
  • How can the same divine action soften some and harden others?
  • How does Pharaoh’s hardening relate to Israel’s unbelief?

Romans 9:19-23 the Potter and the Clay

This lesson treats the potter and clay passage as part of Paul’s dialogue with a Jewish opponent about God’s fairness. It reads the image alongside Jeremiah 18, emphasizing repentance, long-suffering, and human responsibility rather than arbitrary destruction.

  • Who is Paul answering in the potter and clay passage?
  • How does Jeremiah 18 shape the meaning of the image?
  • What are vessels of wrath and vessels of mercy in this lesson?

Romans 9:24-33 the Inclusion of Gentiles, Israel's Faithful Remnant, and Fleshly Israel's Pursuit of Righteousness Without Faith

This lesson brings Romans 9 to its conclusion by showing Paul’s focus on the calling of Jews and Gentiles, the remnant of Israel, and the stumbling of those who pursued righteousness through the law without faith in Christ. It also discusses Hosea, Isaiah, and the stone of stumbling.

  • How does Romans 9:24 clarify Paul’s main subject?
  • What role do Hosea and Isaiah play in Paul’s argument?
  • Why did fleshly Israel stumble at Christ?

Romans 10:1-4 the Folly of Seeking Righteousness in the Law

This lesson opens Romans 10 by explaining Paul’s sorrow over Israel’s attempt to establish righteousness through the Mosaic Law after Christ had fulfilled it. It presents Christ as the end of the law both as its conclusion and as its intended goal.

  • Why does Paul say Israel had zeal without knowledge?
  • What is meant by seeking one’s own righteousness?
  • In what ways is Christ the end of the law?

Romans 10:5-16 Law Righteousness vs. Faith Righteousness and Jewish Objections

This lesson contrasts the righteousness of the law with the righteousness of faith and explains Paul’s use of Moses, Joel, and Isaiah. It emphasizes that Jew and Gentile alike are saved through faith in Christ and that believing the gospel is inseparable from obeying it.

  • What kind of life did the Mosaic Law promise?
  • What does it mean to confess and believe in Christ?
  • Why does Paul stress that whoever calls on the Lord will be saved?
  • How are belief and obedience connected?

Romans 10:17-21: The Differing Response of the Jews and Gentiles.

This lesson explains faith coming through hearing the Word of God and compares the responses of Jews and Gentiles. It also discusses Paul’s use of Moses and Isaiah, including the image of God stretching out His hands to a disobedient people and its Messianic application.

  • Why does Paul say faith comes through hearing?
  • How did the Gentiles respond differently from many Jews?
  • What does it mean for God to stretch out His hands all day?

Romans 11:1-6: God Has Reserved a Remnant of Israel

This lesson begins Romans 11 by showing that God has not cast off His people, because a believing Jewish remnant remains. It uses Paul himself and the 7,000 in Elijah’s day to explain a remnant chosen by grace rather than by the works of the Mosaic Law.

  • How does Paul answer the claim that God rejected Israel?
  • Why is Elijah’s remnant important for Romans 11?
  • What does a remnant according to grace mean?

Romans 11:7-15 the Blinding of Israel and the Inclusion of the Gentiles

This lesson discusses the blinding of unbelieving Israel, the obtaining of righteousness by the chosen remnant, and the extension of reconciliation to the Gentiles. It also considers Paul’s hope that his ministry to the Gentiles might provoke some Jews to salvation.

  • What does it mean that the rest were blinded?
  • How did Israel’s fall bring blessing to the Gentiles?
  • Why did Paul hope to provoke some of his people to salvation?

Romans 11:16-24 Grafting in the Gentiles and Restoring the Jews

This lesson explains Paul’s olive tree image, with Gentiles grafted into the root connected with Abraham and Jews able to be grafted back in through faith. It warns Gentile believers against boasting and stresses one people of God rather than separate trees or flocks.

  • What is the olive tree in Romans 11?
  • Why must Gentile believers not boast against Jewish branches?
  • How can unbelieving Jews be grafted back in?
  • How many flocks does the lesson say Christ will have?

Romans 12:1-2 Living Sacrifices

This lesson marks Paul’s turn to the transformed life after his main argument about Jews, Gentiles, law, grace, and faith. It explains living sacrifices, nonconformity to the world, renewal of the mind, and cooperation with divine grace.

  • What does it mean to present the body as a living sacrifice?
  • How does Paul contrast the world’s fashion with transformation?
  • What role does human cooperation have in renewal?

Romans 12:3-8 a Variety of Gifts in One Body

This lesson covers humility, sober thinking, and diverse gifts in the one body of Christ. It discusses prophecy, ministry, teaching, exhortation, giving, leadership, and mercy as gifts to be used faithfully rather than arrogantly.

  • Why does Paul warn against thinking too highly of oneself?
  • How are different gifts used within one body?
  • What examples of prophecy and mercy are discussed?

Romans 12:9-16 Living the Christ-life

This lesson presents Paul’s description of sincere love, abhorring evil, brotherly affection, zeal, patience, prayer, hospitality, humility, and unity. It emphasizes that these are commands for the transformed Christian life, not mere ideals.

  • What does love without hypocrisy look like?
  • Why must Christians abhor evil and cling to good?
  • How do prayer, hospitality, and humility express the Christ-life?

Romans 12:17-21 Do Not Repay Evil for Evil

This lesson explains Paul’s command not to repay evil for evil in light of Jesus’ teaching on nonretaliation and love for enemies. It treats vengeance as belonging to God and describes overcoming evil with good as a command of the New Covenant.

  • Why must Christians not retaliate against evil?
  • What does it mean to leave vengeance to God?
  • How does loving enemies overcome evil with good?

Romans 13:1-7 Submit to the Governing Authorities Part One

This lesson begins Romans 13 by explaining submission to governing authorities as part of faithful Christian living. It discusses why God instituted governments, the problem of anarchy, and how Christians are to respond even when rulers are evil.

  • Why does Paul tell every soul to be subject to governing authorities?
  • What purpose do governments serve in restraining evil?
  • How does the lesson handle unjust or evil rulers?

Romans 13:1-7 Submit to the Governing Authorities Part Two

This lesson continues the discussion of Romans 13 with questions about public office, taxes, honor, war taxes, and commands that conflict with God’s commands. It presents early Christian reasoning that Christians obey Caesar in what does not offend God but must obey Christ above all.

  • Can Christians hold public office according to the discussion in this lesson?
  • What does Paul mean by tribute, customs, fear, and honor?
  • What should Christians do when Caesar commands what Christ forbids?

Romans 13:8 – 10 Love Fulfills the Law

This lesson explains Paul’s command to owe nothing except the continuing debt of love. It connects love of neighbor with the moral content of the law and with Jesus’ teaching that love fulfills the law and extends even to enemies.

  • Does Romans 13:8 forbid borrowing money?
  • Why is love described as a continuing debt?
  • How does love fulfill the law?

Romans 13:11 – 14 Walk in the Light, Not in Darkness

This lesson calls Christians to wake from spiritual lethargy because salvation is nearer than when they first believed. It contrasts the works of darkness with putting on the Lord Jesus Christ and concludes Paul’s great argument through Romans 13.

  • What kind of sleep does Paul warn against?
  • Why is salvation nearer than when believers first believed?
  • What does it mean to put on the Lord Jesus Christ?

Romans 14:1-9 Scruples About Food

This lesson introduces Romans 14 by addressing Jewish and Gentile believers with different convictions about food. Paul permits continued dietary scruples under certain conditions while commanding believers not to despise or judge one another.

  • Why did some Jewish believers still avoid certain foods?
  • What conditions does Paul place on continued dietary observance?
  • Why must believers not judge one another over food?

Romans 14:10-13 Do Not Judge Your Brother

This lesson grounds Paul’s warning against judging a brother in the coming judgment seat of Christ. It distinguishes correction from condemnation and warns against placing a stumbling block before another believer.

  • Why does Judgment Day make judging a brother so serious?
  • How is correction different from condemnation?
  • What is a stumbling block in this lesson?

Romans 14:14-23: Respecting the Conscience of Others

This lesson explains Paul’s statement that nothing is unclean in itself within the context of foods, not moral evil. It urges believers to pursue peace, edification, and care for weak consciences while also noting that Romans 14 should not be used to impose scruples on others.

  • What does Paul mean when he says nothing is unclean in itself?
  • How can lawful conduct still wound another believer?
  • When should Christians limit liberty for the sake of conscience?
  • When does Paul counsel believers to stand fast in liberty?

Romans 15:1-7 Seeking the Edification of Others

This lesson begins Romans 15 by calling the strong to bear the weaknesses of the weak and seek their neighbor’s edification. It uses Christ’s example, the value of the Old Testament Scriptures, and the need for unity to urge believers to receive one another.

  • What does it mean for the strong to bear the infirmities of the weak?
  • How does Christ’s example shape Christian patience?
  • Why are the Old Testament Scriptures still valuable?
  • How does receiving one another serve unity?

Romans 15:8-14 Prophecies About the Gentiles

This lesson returns to prophecies about Gentile salvation and the unity of Jewish and Gentile believers. It explains Christ as a minister to the circumcision and traces Paul’s use of Old Testament passages showing Gentiles glorifying, rejoicing, praising, and trusting in God.

  • How was Christ a minister to the circumcision?
  • What prophecies does Paul use to show Gentile inclusion?
  • Why should Jews and Gentiles glorify God together?

Romans 15:15-21 Paul’s Ministry to the Gentiles

This lesson explains Paul’s frankness as part of his God-given ministry to the Gentiles. It presents Paul as offering the Gentiles to God through the gospel, rejoicing only in what Christ worked through him, and preaching where Christ had not been named.

  • Why does Paul say he wrote boldly on certain points?
  • How is Paul’s ministry to the Gentiles described as priestly service?
  • Why did Paul seek to preach where Christ had not been named?

Romans 15:22-33 Paul’s Planned Journey to Rome

This lesson covers Paul’s desire to visit Rome on his way to Spain and his prior obligation to deliver alms to the needy saints in Jerusalem. It emphasizes his missionary calling, concern for the poor, and prayer for peace amid opposition and internal tensions.

  • Why had Paul been hindered from visiting Rome?
  • Why did Paul plan to go to Spain?
  • What was the collection for Jerusalem?
  • Why does Paul close this passage by calling God the God of peace?

Romans 16:1-16 Greetings to Various Individuals Part One

This lesson begins Paul’s greetings and highlights his commendation of Phoebe along with his gratitude for Priscilla and Aquila. It shows Paul’s appreciation for women who served and for coworkers who offered hospitality, assistance, and risked themselves for his sake.

  • Why is Romans 16 valuable for understanding Paul’s view of women who served?
  • How does Paul commend Phoebe?
  • What did Priscilla and Aquila do for Paul and the churches?

Romans 16:1-16 Greetings to Various Individuals Part Two

This lesson continues Paul’s greetings, discussing the order of Priscilla and Aquila’s names, the church in their house, Andronicus and Junius or Junia, and the holy kiss. It presents the holy kiss as a practice that expressed unity across social distinctions in the church.

  • Does the order of Priscilla and Aquila’s names prove prominence?
  • How did early Christians understand the church in their house?
  • What questions surround Andronicus and Junius or Junia?
  • What did the holy kiss express?

Romans 16:17-20 Closing Admonition

This lesson explains Paul’s warning to mark and avoid those who cause divisions and offenses contrary to apostolic teaching. It connects divisiveness with serious sin, warns against flattering deceivers, and ends with hope that God will bruise Satan under believers’ feet.

  • Why is causing division in the church so serious?
  • Who are believers told to mark and avoid?
  • How do flattering teachers deceive the simple?
  • What does it mean that God will bruise Satan under their feet?

Romans 16: 21-27 Greetings from Paul’s Fellow Workers and Closing Doxology

This final lesson covers greetings from Paul’s fellow workers, including Timothy, Tertius, Gaius, and others, and discusses the closing doxology. It emphasizes the obedience of faith, the revealed mystery of the gospel, and glory to the only wise God through Jesus Christ.

  • Who sends greetings from Paul’s circle of coworkers?
  • What role did Tertius have in the writing of Romans?
  • How does the closing doxology connect faith and obedience?
  • Why does Paul give glory to the only wise God?

About the Book

Cover of Romans Commentary, Chapters 9–16 by David W. Bercot

How Romans was understood before Augustine and Luther

  • Author: David W. Bercot
  • First published: 2024
  • Publisher: Scroll Publishing Co.
  • Pages: 448
  • Audiobook length: ~16 hours
  • ISBN: 9780924722356

This is the second half of David Bercot's verse-by-verse audio commentary on the Book of Romans, covering chapters 9 through 16. The complete printed volume (Historic Faith Commentary Series on Romans, Scroll Publishing, 2024, 448 pp. hardcover, ISBN 9780924722356) covers all 16 chapters.

Romans 9–16 contains some of the most contested passages in the New Testament — chapters that have been used to support divergent doctrines of predestination, election, government, the church and Israel, the role of the Mosaic Law in the Christian life, and Christian conduct toward enemies and authorities. Bercot walks verse by verse through this material, listening to how Christians of the first four centuries — many of whom knew the apostles personally or lived in Paul's own culture — actually heard these passages.

You will hear the same explanations they would have heard. As you will see, those early Christians understood Romans quite differently than do most Christians today, because they lived prior to the two major reinterpretations of Romans: that of Augustine and that of Luther. After hearing the early Christian understanding, you can decide whether the entire church got Romans wrong from the beginning — or if Christians today are misreading this important book.

Listening to this course alongside Romans Commentary, Chapters 1–8 gives you the complete commentary in audio form.

About the author: David W. Bercot is a former evangelical-turned-Anabaptist attorney and historian. He has spent four decades studying the writings of the early Christians (A.D. 90–325) and is the editor of A Dictionary of Early Christian Beliefs and the founder of Scroll Publishing Co.

Praise from Readers

What readers and reviewers have said about Romans Commentary, Chapters 9–16. These are short, attributed quotes from public reviews on Goodreads, Amazon, the publisher's site, and independent book reviewers.

Enables the reader to share the same experience that a Christian living in the first four centuries would have experienced when hearing Romans explained on a given Sunday.

Editorial description, Scroll Publishing

Be the first to review this course

No reviews yet on this course. If this teaching has been a blessing to you, a short review is one of the most powerful ways to help others find it — honest reviews help this course rank higher in Google so more people discover the historic faith.

Help spread the message. Every honest review helps more people discover this teaching through Google and word of mouth. If this course has helped you, sharing a few sentences is one of the simplest ways to support the mission — it’s free, takes about a minute, and reaches people we may never meet.
Romans Commentary Chapters 9-16

Preview this Course

+74 enrolled
Start Course

Open Registration

Course Includes

  • 34 Lessons
  • 34 Quizzes
  • Course Certificate