Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Radical Christian Living  /  How Obedience Can Become Pharisaism  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 8
In discussing Matthew 23:25–26 (“cleanse the inside of the cup”), Bercot notes that many church standards focus almost exclusively on outward markers (dress, grooming, transportation, colors), which trains people to “size others up” externally; where have you seen outward standards shape judgments about someone’s spirituality, and what would it take to retrain your instincts toward the “inner man”?
Another way to ask: Bercot says many church standards focus on outward things and teach people to judge others by what they see. Where have you seen outward rules affect how people judge someone’s faith, and what would help you focus more on the heart?

Direct Answer Bercot teaches that heavy outward rule systems can condition believers to evaluate spirituality by visible markers, so retraining requires consciously prioritizing the “inner man” and refusing to treat external conformity as the main measure of faithfulness.

Support from Transcript:

  • He quotes Matthew 23:25–26 about cleaning “the outside of the cup” while inside is corrupt, and Jesus’ command: “first cleanse the inside…that the outside…may be clean also.”
  • He observes standards often focus on “dress…grooming…transportation…the color of our vehicles…the color of our clothes,” while “very few…relate to the inner man.”
  • He even says he can’t think of any church rules “that pertain to the inner man.”
  • He describes the effect: it “does cause us to start looking at people from primarily an external perspective,” thinking we can “size them up spiritually.”
  • He gives examples of what people notice when someone leaves: “skirt and a blouse instead of a cape dress” or “no longer wearing a head covering.”
  • He warns the deeper issue may be ignored: the person might “actually has more love…than they used to.”
Discussion Follow-ups What practical steps could your church take to talk about love, mercy, and inner transformation as concretely as it talks about dress?

Jumpstarter 8 of 10
Back Questions Next