Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
The Myth of Christian America  /  MCA (4 of 14): Geneva: When Puritans Ruled  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 9
Cromwell’s slaughter at Drogheda and Parliament’s “National Day of Thanksgiving” (“an act both of justice… and mercy to others”) are presented as Christians praising God while acting like “pagan barbarians”; what does that reveal about the danger of mixing certainty of salvation with violence, and how should the teachings of Jesus and the early church confront such “holy” justifications?
Another way to ask: What danger shows up when Christians are sure they’re saved and still use violence, like at Drogheda, and even thank God for it? How should Jesus’ teaching and the early church push back against “holy” reasons for cruelty?

Direct Answer Bercot presents Drogheda as a warning that people who feel spiritually certain can commit extreme violence and still call it God’s “mercy,” so religious language can sanctify brutality instead of restraining it.

Support from Transcript:

  • After breaching the city, Cromwell says, “we refused them quarter,” and “put to the sword the whole number of the defenders…I do not think 30…escaped.”
  • He reports survivors were kept “for Barbados,” and Bercot adds Irish accounts say civilians—“men, women, and children alike”—were included.
  • Cromwell frames the massacre as God’s work: “It is pleased God to bless our endeavors,” and claims the terror produced would “save much effusion of blood through the goodness of God.”
  • Parliament declares a “National Day of Thanksgiving,” calling the execution “an act both of justice… and the mercy to others.”
  • Bercot concludes the Puritans acted like “pagan barbarians,” with the main difference being they “praised God in every other sentence.”
  • He quotes Cromwell attributing soldiers’ courage swings to “the Spirit of God,” insisting “God alone have all the glory.”
Discussion Follow-ups The transcript doesn’t quote Jesus’ teachings directly here, but Bercot repeatedly contrasts Puritan coercion with early Christian “separation from the world.” How would that early Christian outlook judge thanking God for terror and mass killing?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next