Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
In the wheat-and-weeds parable, Bercot critiques both Augustine’s use of state force to fill the church and the Anabaptist overreaction that reassigns the “field” to the world in a way that reverses the parable’s sequence; what does this chapter force you to hold together about church purity, discipline (Matthew 18), and the reality of hidden hypocrisy?
Another way to ask: What does this chapter make you hold together about church purity and discipline (Matthew 18) while also admitting some hypocrisy stays hidden for a while? How do you avoid going too far in either direction?

Direct Answer Based on the transcript, Matthew 13 forces us to hold together three truths: we should pursue a disciplined and clean church, we must not use coercion to fill the church, and yet we must accept that the visible church will still contain hypocrites and hidden sin until the final separation.

Support from Transcript:

  • He summarizes the basic meaning: there will be “wicked people within the church… hypocrites,” and this shouldn’t “cause us to stumble.”
  • He criticizes Augustine’s misuse: using “the army… power of the state to make everybody attend church,” producing a state church mixed with “people who should have never been in the church.”
  • He says Anabaptists rightly reacted: the church should be “called out,” with believers’ baptism and commitment “to dying to sin… a pure life.”
  • But he says their overreaction misreads the parable because it reverses the order of planting: in Jesus’s story “the wheat is first planted… then Satan… plants the weeds.”
  • He balances purity with realism: “we are to put wicked people out of the church” (Matthew 18), but “you can’t read everyone’s heart,” so some weeds remain hidden.
Discussion Follow-ups How can a church practice real discipline without pretending it can guarantee who is wheat and who is weed?