Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Historical Kingdom Christian Movements  /  The Novatianists  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 9
Socrates’ stories highlight Novatianist costly faithfulness (dismantling and rebuilding a church to avoid demolition), disciplined leadership (Bishop Paul fasting, prison visitation, care for the poor), and apparent divine favor (the draining baptismal pool; the church spared from fire)—how should we evaluate such narratives without becoming naïve, and what do they suggest God may honor even in a marginalized or persecuted community?
Another way to ask: How should we judge stories of Novatianist sacrifice, discipline, and possible miracles without being gullible, and what might those stories show about what God may honor in an unpopular or persecuted church?

Direct Answer Based on the transcript, we should receive these narratives with humility: they come through Socrates, a later historian, and Bercot presents them as reports rather than airtight proof. Still, they suggest God may honor disciplined, sacrificial faithfulness and can vindicate marginalized communities in ways even outsiders notice.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot says we would know “almost nothing” after Novatian’s death without Socrates (writing around 439), nearly 200 years later.
  • He notes Socrates was Catholic but “sympathetic” because he “couldn’t help but notice their godliness” versus a “worldly Catholic Church.”
  • Costly faithfulness example: they dismantled their church “stone by stone… timber by timber” before soldiers arrived, rebuilt elsewhere, then later returned it.
  • Bishop Paul’s disciplined life: “fasted and prayed regularly,” “took care of the poor,” “regularly visited those in prison,” and interceded before judges.
  • Reported miracles: the baptismal water “vanished” twice exposing fraud; fire destroyed surrounding buildings but their church “escaped unscathed,” leading many to “special veneration.”
Discussion Follow-ups What criteria help us avoid gullibility while still honoring credible testimonies of God’s work? How might disciplined mercy to the poor and prisoners function as a stronger witness than public influence?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next