Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 8
If a command, doctrine, or practice appears in only a few passages of Scripture, how should serious Christians discern whether they have been minimizing it because it is truly marginal or because it is inconvenient to modern habits and church traditions?
Another way to ask: If a command, teaching, or practice appears in only a few Bible verses, how can Christians tell if it is truly less important or if we ignore it because it does not fit modern habits or church traditions?

Direct Answer

According to Bercot’s reasoning, Christians should not minimize a teaching merely because it appears in only a few passages; they should ask whether those few passages contain an important truth that must be received. The transcript does not specifically discuss modern habits or church traditions, but it warns against dismissing minority passages too easily.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot says it would not make sense to ignore the majority of verses in favor of only one or two. - However, he adds, β€œI am not so sure that it is right to ignore the one or the two either.” - He says an account or teaching is not invalid just because it lacks support in other passages. - Luke alone records Jesus healing the slave’s ear, yet Bercot clearly treats that detail as valid. - John alone identifies Peter as the swordsman, and Bercot asks whether we should ignore John’s statement. - He concludes that β€œthe few passages in Scripture contain important truths that must not be ignored.”

Discussion Follow-ups

A useful question is whether we are weighing Scripture carefully or using rarity as an excuse for avoidance.