Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Bible and Early Church History  /  The Truth About the Catacombs  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 9
He argues that after Constantine, masses entered the church “without evidence…of genuine new birth,” which “changed the whole character of Christianity,” including the shift from honoring martyrs to treating them as helpers to whom people prayed; what does this suggest about God’s patience and judgment when the church gains political favor, and where do you see modern parallels of “baptized but unregenerate” cultural Christianity shaping doctrine and practice?
Another way to ask: Bercot says after Constantine many people joined the church without real new life, and church life changed, including how people treated martyrs. What might this show about God’s patience and judgment when the church gets political power, and where do you see similar “Christian in name only” patterns today affecting beliefs and practices?

Direct Answer Bercot’s teaching suggests that political favor can flood the church with unconverted people and produce major distortions in doctrine and practice, such as praying to martyrs instead of simply honoring them. The transcript doesn’t directly speak about God’s “patience and judgment,” but it strongly implies that corruption and doctrinal drift followed the church becoming favored by the state.

Support from Transcript:

  • After the Edict of Milan, Constantine “legalized Christianity” and made it “the favored religion.”
  • Bercot says “masses of pagans… began thronging into the church… baptized,” yet “no evidence whatsoever of any genuine new birth.”
  • Result: “it obviously changed the whole character of Christianity.”
  • Specific shift: from high esteem to a belief martyrs “could help the living,” which Bercot calls “a radical change.”
  • He contrasts earlier practice: commemorations honored martyrs, but “they didn’t pray to them.”
  • He links this to the later saints system “predominant” in Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox tradition.
Discussion Follow-ups What modern church practices may be driven more by cultural momentum than regeneration? How can churches pursue growth without confusing baptism or membership with new birth?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next