Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Will The Real Heretics Please Stand Up  /  Chapter 6: What They Believed About Salvation  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 8
When a listener says, “It sounds to me like they needed to read their Bibles more,” Bercot counters with the massive NT citation numbers (Clement of Alexandria ~2,400; Tertullian ~7,000; ~32,000 pre-Nicaea)—how does that data pressure the way we dismiss uncomfortable theology, and what does it imply about the early church’s interpretive priorities (Jesus’ words, Paul, James, Hebrews)?
Another way to ask: Bercot says early Christians quoted the New Testament a huge amount. How does that challenge the idea that they just didn’t know their Bibles, and what does it show about which parts of the New Testament they focused on most?

Direct Answer The citation data pressures us not to dismiss early-Christian views as simple biblical ignorance; Bercot argues they knew Scripture deeply but interpreted it by giving Jesus’ teachings and the whole apostolic witness equal weight with Paul. It implies their priority was reading Paul alongside Jesus, James, Hebrews, and other texts rather than elevating Romans and Galatians above all.

Support from Transcript:

  • A woman complains: “It sounds to me like they needed to read their Bibles more.”
  • Bercot replies: “But the early Christians did read their Bibles.”
  • He cites McDowell/Greenley: NT could “virtually be reconstructed” from early writers’ quotations.
  • Numbers: Clement of Alexandria has “2,400” NT quotes; Tertullian quotes the NT “more than 7,000 times”; Geisler/Nix estimate “32,000 citations… prior to… Nicaea.”
  • He says they were aware of Paul: “Paul personally taught men like Clement of Rome.”
  • Interpretive priority: they “didn’t put Paul’s letters… on a pedestal above the teachings of Jesus,” and they weighed Matthew 7:21, Matthew 24:13, John 5:28–29, Revelation 22:12, plus even Paul in 1 Timothy 4:16.
Discussion Follow-ups How might our interpretive habits change if we refused to “nullify” hard passages by favoring a few key texts? Which sayings of Jesus should control how we read Paul?

Jumpstarter 8 of 10
Back Questions Next