Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Will The Real Heretics Please Stand Up  /  Chapter 3: Citizens of another Kingdom  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 10
Clement’s line (“A person who does not do what God has commanded shows he really does not believe God”) and the claim “We don’t speak great things. We live them” collide with modern habits of separating faith from obedience; where do you most rely on “trust language” while resisting costly obedience, and how does the early Christians’ willingness to be “martyrs/witnesses” challenge your understanding of assurance, freedom, and God’s protection?
Another way to ask: Clement says that if you don’t obey God, you don’t really believe him, and early Christians said they lived their faith instead of just talking. Where do you say you trust God but resist hard obedience, and how does their willingness to suffer as witnesses challenge your view of assurance, freedom, and God’s protection?

Direct Answer The transcript pushes us to see “trust” as proven by obedience, not merely words; the early Christians’ readiness to suffer as “witnesses/martyrs” challenges any assurance that ignores costly obedience and calls us to trust God’s protection without using worldly means.

Support from Transcript:

  • Clement: “A person who does not do what God has commanded shows he really does not believe God.”
  • Bercot summarizes their mindset: claiming trust while refusing obedience “was a contradiction,” and their faith was “more than just verbal.”
  • Early Christians said, “We don’t speak great things. We live them.”
  • They obeyed “childlike” and “literal[ly],” not demanding reasons: “Who… is so irreverent as to… demand explanations from God?”
  • On witness and assurance: persecution made “witness” read as “martyr,” e.g., Antipas as “faithful martyr.”
  • On freedom and protection: they stood with “naked hands,” refusing “human means” to preserve the church, trusting God alone; Origen: God permits persecution and also gives peace.
Discussion Follow-ups Does your sense of security come from God’s promises or from control and comfort? What would change if you believed obedience is the normal language of faith?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done