Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 1

David Bercot compares modern “Bible-believing Christians” ignoring the early christians to the Pharisees dodging Jesus’ question about John the Baptist’s authority; where do you see that same “we don’t know” posture in your own church background, and what would it cost you personally to take a real position?

Another way to ask: Where have you seen your church background say “we don’t know” to avoid taking a stand, like the Pharisees did? What might it cost you personally to take a clear position?

Direct Answer Based on David Bercot’s teaching, the “we don’t know” posture shows up when Christians avoid taking any clear stance on whether the early Christians’ beliefs and lifestyle were trustworthy, because admitting they were right would challenge our own comfort and doctrines. Taking a real position could cost us pride, reputation, and possibly changing cherished beliefs and habits.

Support from Transcript:

He says modern Bible-believing Christians “simply ignore the early Christians…disregard their writings.”
He compares this to the Pharisees answering Jesus, “We don’t know,” to avoid the consequences of either option.
He explains the dilemma: if we say the early Christians were correct, “we would have to acknowledge that our lifestyles and many of our own beliefs are not.”
Yet we resist calling them heretics because we “can’t deny their unconquerable faith and genuine Christian love.”
He adds a practical consequence: if they were heretics, “our New Testament canon was assembled by heretics.”

Discussion Follow-ups What would your church have to re-examine first—lifestyle, salvation teaching, or attitudes toward other Christians—if it stopped ignoring the early church?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 1 of 10