Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 1
Calvin insists that “there exists a plain and complete guideline” for Christian moral living in the law of Moses, and that “whoever adds to or takes anything from it exceeds the limits”; what, in this chapter, makes Bercot say the early Christians would have called that “a false opinion,” and where does that leave how you personally use the Old Testament to decide what obedience looks like?
Another way to ask: Calvin says the law of Moses is the full guide for Christian living, but Bercot says early Christians would call that wrong. What in this chapter leads him to say that, and how do you use the Old Testament today to decide what obedience looks like?

Direct Answer Based on David Bercot’s teaching, the early Christians would call Calvin’s claim “a false opinion” because they believed Jesus’ moral teaching *surpasses* Moses and is aimed at a heavenly kingdom, so Christians must cling to Christ’s commands even when they go beyond or differ from Old Testament moral allowances.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot quotes Calvin claiming the “law of Moses” is a “plain and complete guideline” and that adding/taking away “exceeds the limits.”
  • Bercot immediately contrasts this with early Christianity: “the moral teachings of Christ surpassed the moral teachings of the Old Testament.”
  • He says they did not think “God Himself had changed,” but that Jesus “went to the core of the law and tapped its true spiritual meaning.”
  • They believed OT commandments were “for an earthly kingdom,” while NT teaching is for “citizens of a heavenly kingdom.”
  • Their literal obedience to Jesus produced practices unlike modern evangelical life (he mentions divorce, wealth, lawsuits, and then swearing, war, and capital punishment).
Discussion Follow-ups The transcript doesn’t give a step-by-step method for using the Old Testament, but it pushes you to let Jesus’ teachings be the controlling standard when deciding what obedience looks like.

Jumpstarter 1 of 10
Back Questions Next