Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 6 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 6
In the publishing examples (Crying Wind, Satan’s Underground), publishers withdrew books yet reassigned rights elsewhere, and exaggerated miracle/testimony stories kept circulating; what do these examples suggest about incentives in the Christian marketplace, and how should “kingdom people” decide what they will buy, promote, platform, or refuse—even when the stories feel inspiring?
Another way to ask: What do these publishing stories show about what gets rewarded in the Christian market, even when stories are stretched or false? How should Christians decide what to buy, share, or promote, even if it feels inspiring?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests the Christian marketplace often rewards sensational stories even when they are false or exaggerated; kingdom people should refuse to support dishonesty and choose truth over inspiration.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot recounts a bookstore experience: they carried Crying Wind, but “the publisher had concluded that her testimony wasn't true, and so it had discontinued publishing the book.”
  • He learned “quite a few… testimonies and miracle stories… were either completely false or exaggerated.”
  • In Satan’s Underground, investigators found strong evidence “the book was a fraud,” and the original publisher “withdrew the book.”
  • Yet the market kept it alive: that publisher then “assign[ed] the publishing rights to another publisher,” showing continued demand despite credibility issues.
  • He concludes broadly: “today's Christianity fosters a culture of dishonesty,” implying incentives favor sales, excitement, and reputation over truth.
  • His kingdom standard is clear: Christians must be “of the truth,” with truthfulness permeating everything.
Discussion Follow-ups What should matter most when choosing what to read or recommend: impact or accuracy? How should Christians respond when they learn a beloved testimony story is unreliable?