Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 1

The Donatists began by wanting “the new perks that Constantine was offering” and even asked the emperor to intervene in church disputes; what does their later change of heart suggest about how God can use “losing” or disappointment to expose what the church has become?

Another way to ask: The Donatists first wanted Constantine’s benefits and asked him to step into church fights, but later changed their minds. What might that show about how God can use losing or disappointment to reveal what the church has really become?

Direct Answer Based on David Bercot’s teaching, the Donatists’ “losing” became a mercy because it forced them to see the institutional church clearly and turn back toward the Kingdom of God. Their disappointment exposed the church’s worldliness and broke their desire for imperial approval.

Support from Transcript:

They “wanted the new perks that Constantine was offering” and “didn’t hesitate to ask the emperor to intervene.”
“All of the traditional decisions went against the Donatists,” and Bercot says “it proved to be a blessing.”
Their losses “forced them to step back and reevaluate what the institutional church had become.”
It “opened their eyes” that the church was “no longer a holy body” but “a worldly institution” that “promoted the rich and the powerful.”
As a result, they “completely dropped their original desire to win the emperor’s acceptance” and “refocus[ed] their attention on the Kingdom of God.”

Discussion Follow-ups What disappointments in our own church experience might be exposing unhealthy dependence on power, status, or “perks”? How can we respond by refocusing on Jesus’ Kingdom rather than trying harder to win the system?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 1 of 10