Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in
Question 4
The lesson repeatedly states early Christians believed “children are born morally innocent” and “do not bear the guilt of Adam’s sin,” even giving thanks if a child dies “as for one who has passed through the world without sins”; how does that early Christian posture press on modern assumptions about infant guilt, baptism, “age of accountability,” and what it means for God to be just?
Another way to ask: If children are born morally innocent and don’t carry Adam’s guilt, what does that do to modern views on infant guilt, baptism, the “age of accountability,” and God’s justice?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests early Christians saw God’s justice as excluding infant guilt: children are “morally innocent” and not chargeable with Adam’s guilt, so God does not damn them for Adam’s act. That presses modern assumptions by challenging any view that treats infants as already guilty or condemned, while still allowing discussion of accountability as a later, conscious reality.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot states plainly: “Children are born morally innocent. They do not bear the guilt of Adam’s sin.”
  • Aristides is quoted: if a child dies, Christians “give thanks to God the more, as for one who has passed through the world without sins.”
  • Hermas: such ones are “like infant children in whose hearts no evil originates.”
  • Irenaeus: speaks of “innocent children who have had no sense of evil.”
  • Tertullian (though teaching fallen nature) still held “infants and young children are not chargeable with sin until they reach the age of accountability.”
  • Bercot later concludes: “until Augustine…absolutely no one taught that we somehow inherit Adam’s guilt…making them liable to eternal damnation.”
Discussion Follow-ups The transcript does not fully develop baptism practice here, but it forces the question: if infants lack guilt, what is baptism understood to address? How should “justice” shape your assumptions about accountability?