Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 2
The chapter critiques the common Protestant claim that “obedience plays no role in salvation” and that thinking righteousness matters is what “endangers your salvation”; how does that accusation land when you read Jesus’s opening blessing (“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven”), and what does it suggest about what God is actually looking for in people?
Another way to ask: Some Protestants say obedience has nothing to do with salvation and that caring about righteousness is dangerous—how does that fit with Jesus blessing the “poor in spirit”? What does that say about what God is looking for in people?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests that reading Jesus’ blessing honestly undercuts the idea that obedience is irrelevant, because “poor in spirit” was historically tied to humility and willing submission to God, not to excusing obedience. It suggests God is looking for people who choose humility, tremble at His commandments, and live obediently.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot says anyone “intellectually honest” sees the Sermon on the Mount goes “strongly against” the message that obedience “plays no role in your salvation.”
  • He criticizes the modern fear that the only thing that “endanger[s] your salvation” is thinking “living a righteous life affects that salvation.”
  • He argues evangelicals “found a way to try to sneak that into the Sermon on the Mount,” using “poor in spirit” as a key verse.
  • Chrysostom: “It means the humble and contrite in mind…He blesses those who are humbled by choice…awestruck and tremble at the commandments of God.”
  • Origen: those “obedient to the Word of God…by their obedience…deserve the kingdom of heaven.”
Discussion Follow-ups How does your church normally explain “poor in spirit,” and does that explanation naturally produce obedience or minimize it?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next