Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 10
The chapter challenges the common claim that “righteousness exceeding the scribes and Pharisees” means an impossible standard designed to drive us to passive reliance; based on Bercot’s description of Pharisaic externalism and Jesus’s demand for inward mercy and love, what would “exceeding” righteousness look like in concrete relationships (money, forgiveness, enemies, speech, purity), and what would have to change inside you for that to be real rather than outward?
Another way to ask: If “righteousness greater than the Pharisees” means real mercy and love from the heart (not just rule-keeping), what would that look like in daily life—money, forgiveness, enemies, speech, and purity? What would need to change inside you for it to be real and not just outward?

Direct Answer According to Bercot, “exceeding” righteousness is not an impossible standard meant to cancel obedience, but a deeper, inward righteousness focused on mercy and love rather than outward show. It would look like relationships shaped by genuine mercy, forgiveness, and love of neighbor flowing from an inner change, not merely external rule-keeping.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot critiques the modern explanation: “we have to do something impossible…then…throw ourselves on the Lord,” calling it another attempt to insert Luther into the sermon.
  • He points out Jesus’ own critique of Pharisees: they are “whitewashed graves,” focused on outward details like tithing spices.
  • They neglected “the important things…being merciful…loving their fellow man,” and the two great commands: love God and love neighbor.
  • Jesus’ goal: “change from the inside,” caring more about whether you are “a merciful, forgiving person” than merely fulfilling outward commands.
  • He adds Jesus still wants obedience “even the least of his commandments,” but with focus on “the important ones that come from the inside.”
  • Another early-Christian angle: our righteousness exceeds theirs because Christ’s “law of liberty…exceeds the Mosaic law.”
Discussion Follow-ups Which is harder for you: visible religious correctness, or inward mercy and forgiveness when it costs you something in real relationships?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done