Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Intimacy with God  /  Chapter 14: Scripture, the Basis of Truth  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 4
The chapter’s unusual analogy compares Mary’s continued virginity to Scripture “giving birth through the truth” while remaining “virgin in the concealment of the mysteries”; how does this analogy shape the way you think about Scripture’s clarity versus mystery, and what posture does it demand when you come to hard or hidden teachings?
Another way to ask: How does the Mary-and-Scripture comparison shape how you see Scripture as both clear and mysterious, and how should that affect your attitude toward hard-to-understand teachings?

Direct Answer Based on the transcript, Scripture truly produces (or “gives birth to”) truth, yet it also retains “concealment of the mysteries,” so the right posture is reverent patience—letting Scripture speak without forcing it to say what our desires want.

Support from Transcript:

  • He argues Mary “was…still physically…a virgin,” and then says, “The Scriptures of the Lord are like that to us.”
  • “They give birth through the truth, but they remain virgin in the concealment of the mysteries of truth.”
  • “Those who know God recognize that the Scriptures have brought forth truth,” but heretics “dismiss the Scriptures as not giving birth to truth.”
  • The faithful “let the word speak” and “build proofs from it,” rather than twisting meaning.
  • He warns others “distort Scripture to agree with their lust (2 Peter 3:16).”
Discussion Follow-ups When Scripture feels unclear, do you tend to force certainty quickly, or do you accept “mystery” while still holding that Scripture truly “gives birth” to truth?

Jumpstarter 4 of 10
Back Questions Next