Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Intimacy with God  /  Chapter 13: What about divisions in the body of Christ  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 5
The medical illustration says a sick idolater shouldn’t delay turning to God because physicians disagree; what does this reveal about the chapter’s view of the human condition (sin/idolatry as illness) and about God’s posture toward those who come for “treatment”?
Another way to ask: The chapter compares sin and idolatry to being sick and needing treatment. What does that say about how it views people’s spiritual condition, and how does it picture God toward those who come for help?

Direct Answer The chapter portrays idolatry as a spiritual sickness that urgently needs healing, and it presents turning to God as receiving real “treatment,” implying God is ready to restore rather than waiting for people to solve every dispute first.

Support from Transcript:

  • He compares heretical disagreement to medicine: “physicians hold conflicting opinions, yet they still all treat patients.”
  • He asks whether a sick person would “refuse to go to the doctor because of the differing schools of medicine,” answering, “Of course not.”
  • He applies it directly: “he who is sick in soul and who worships idols can’t use the existence of heretical sects as an excuse to delay turning to God.”
  • He describes conversion as healing: “receiving treatment for his soul’s health.”
  • His overall argument treats excuses as dangerous: those who make “unfounded excuses face certain condemnation,” so delay is morally serious, not neutral.
Discussion Follow-ups If idolatry is an illness, what might “treatment” look like in a church community beyond initial belief?

Jumpstarter 5 of 10
Back Questions Next