Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
In God We Don't Trust  /  Chapter 6: A Shining City on a Hill  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 1
Winthrop warned that if the colonists “deal falsely with our God,” God could “withdraw his present help,” making them “a story and a byword through the world”; what picture of God’s active involvement with a community’s public witness is assumed in that warning, and how does it challenge the way many Christians think about reputational “damage control”?
Another way to ask: When Winthrop warned that God could pull back His help and make the colony look foolish to the world, what does that say about how God affects a community’s public reputation? How does that challenge the way Christians today try to manage their image instead of taking sin seriously?

Direct Answer Winthrop assumes God actively supports or withdraws help from a community based on its faithfulness, and that this directly shapes the community’s public reputation. That challenges “damage control” thinking by suggesting the core issue isn’t managing appearances but living truthfully before God.

Support from Transcript:

  • Winthrop warns that if they “deal falsely with our God… [he will] withdraw his present help from us,” and then they will become “a story and a byword through the world.”
  • He connects their public witness to outsiders: “We shall open the mouths of enemies to speak evil of the ways of God.”
  • Bercot says Winthrop’s words were “prophetic” because Puritan New England later “has given the world a negative view of Christians.”
  • The chapter implies the reputational harm came from real actions, not mere misunderstanding: “what happened in Puritan New England largely flavors the view… toward conservative, Bible-believing Christians.”
  • The narrative later shows how conduct (autocracy, massacre) contradicted their stated ideals, leading to shame and criticism.
Discussion Follow-ups If God’s “help” is tied to faithfulness, what kinds of repentance and change would matter more than public relations statements?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10
Back Questions Next