Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
Bercot describes both sides calling for prayer and fasting, clergy on both sides claiming God’s will, and “born again” believers contradicting one another; what does this reveal about the danger of confusing God’s kingdom with national cause, and how can Christians test whether their “God is on our side” language is actually self-deception?
Another way to ask: Bercot describes both sides praying and claiming God was with them, even “born again” believers disagreeing. What does this show about mixing God’s kingdom with a national cause, and how can Christians check if “God is on our side” is really self-deception?

Direct Answer The transcript shows that religious language can be used to baptize national causes on both sides of a conflict, proving that “God is on our side” claims can be self-deception; the test implied is whether our actions align with Christ’s commands toward fellow Christians and enemies.

Support from Transcript:

  • He notes symmetry: Congress called for “a day of prayer and fasting,” and “King George called for the very same thing.”
  • He says clergy on both sides told soldiers they were doing “God's will,” and “born again” believers in America supported the revolution while “born again” believers in England condemned it.
  • He observes both camps interpreted events as divine proof: English victories “was proof that God was on their side,” and American victories were “proof” to Americans.
  • He quotes John Wesley’s outrage at Christians killing “flesh of their flesh and bone of their bone” over “the mode of taxation.”
  • He ties the core issue to allegiance: most showed politics above Christianity, even killing fellow believers—contrary to Christ’s teaching.
Discussion Follow-ups When do prayer and “God talk” become a cover for what we already wanted? What Christ-centered questions should we ask before claiming God endorses our side?