Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 7
Bercot’s Jehovah’s Witness story highlights a mindset where “you’re not allowed to question it” and where members assume they “have a complete understanding of the Bible”; where do you see similar patterns of untouchable authority or taboo questions in modern evangelical culture (even if unspoken), and what does that do to honest truth-seeking?
Another way to ask: Where do you see “don’t question this” attitudes or taboo questions in modern evangelical culture? How does that affect honest searching for truth?

Direct Answer The transcript doesn’t name specific evangelical examples, but Bercot’s principle suggests similar patterns appear anywhere questioning is discouraged and people assume their group already has “the truth.” That atmosphere blocks honest examination of Scripture and makes it hard for the Spirit to correct errors.

Support from Transcript:

  • In Jehovah’s Witnesses, “everything that’s given to you, you have to accept as being true,” and “you’re not allowed to question it.”
  • He says they assume they have “a complete understanding of the Bible,” so they cannot honestly examine what Scripture teaches.
  • His door-to-door story shows a fake “examination” where the person claimed he compared churches, but his “mind was already made up.”
  • Bercot warns: “if you have that kind of mindset, don’t think that the Holy Spirit can teach you anything.”
  • He adds: “if you’re in a church that doesn’t allow you to question things…[and] you believe there’s no possibility that your church or denomination could be wrong,” truth-seeking becomes “very difficult.”
Discussion Follow-ups What topics in your church culture bring social costs for asking honest questions, and how could leaders create space for careful, Scripture-based examination?

Jumpstarter 7 of 10
Back Questions Next