Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in
Question 1
Finny described his wife reading 1 Corinthians 11 at the gym, weeping, and saying, “I’m not doing this,” even though “nearly all” the commentaries they read dismissed it as “just something for that culture”; what does that moment reveal about how God confronts us through Scripture, and how do you discern whether your discomfort is the Spirit’s conviction or simply fear of social consequences?
Another way to ask: What does that gym moment show about how God can challenge us through the Bible? How can you tell if your discomfort is the Holy Spirit convicting you or just fear of what people will think?

Direct Answer That moment shows Scripture confronting a believer personally, not just intellectually—so strongly that it overruled what “nearly all” experts said. Finny suggests discernment happens by slowly letting the text speak “verse by verse” until your “heart of hearts” can’t escape what God is saying, rather than reacting mainly to anticipated shame.

Support from Transcript:

  • Laura read 1 Corinthians 11 and was “in tears,” saying, “I’m not doing this,” showing the passage pressed on her conscience, not merely her curiosity.
  • Finny and his wife went to Harvard Divinity School Library and found “nearly all” said it was “just something for that culture,” yet she “was not content with that.”
  • They recognized “in our heart of hearts, we couldn’t read the Bible and walk away with a different conclusion.”
  • Finny names the real cost: couples who do this “will incur a lot of shame, a lot of insults from friends, from family.”
  • His method for confidence/clarity: “going through the Word of God very slowly, very carefully, verse by verse, line by line… and let the Bible speak for itself.”
  • He urges a “childlike… humble” posture that “simply receive[s] it and believe[s] it,” not a proud posture.
Discussion Follow-ups Finny doesn’t give a simple test for “conviction vs fear,” but he does imply fear shrinks when the text is patiently studied and believed. What happens in you when expert opinion conflicts with your plain reading of Scripture?