Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 5
Early Christians taught that baptism washes away only past sins, and that sins after baptism must be cleansed through repentance God tests. Why did this teaching shake Jason Willis so deeply, and what would it mean for your life if it is true?
Another way to ask: Early Christians taught that baptism only washes away past sins, and later sins need repentance that God tests. Why did this shake Jason Willis, and what would it mean for you if it is true?

Direct Answer

Jason Willis had been taught that all his sins were forgiven at once. If baptism cleanses only what came before, then decades of later sin would still need repentance, and he says this is where his Protestant worldview began to crumble.

Support from the Message

- Clement of Alexandria says deeds done before baptism are forgiven at baptism, while those committed after must be purified. - Jason saw two Christianities, and only one could be true: all sins washed away in a moment of faith, or only what came before. - Sins after baptism are cleansed through repentance that must be good and pure, and one a person can abide in. - Jason says this teaching almost destroyed Christianity for him, and he asked what good the cross was if he could not sin. - He says it rebuilt his understanding of salvation.

Discussion Follow-up

If your sins since baptism are still a matter for repentance, what would you need to bring to God? How would that change this week?