Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 9
Bercot cites his own book’s discussion of John 4, arguing the surprise at the well was ethnic (Jew/Samaritan), not gender-based (“For Jews have no dealings with Samaritans”); how does his reading of that passage confront common preaching tropes, and what does it imply about the danger of building doctrines on a single, out-of-context line (“they marveled that He talked with a woman”)?
Another way to ask: How does Bercot’s reading of John 4 challenge the common way this story is preached? What danger is there in building big beliefs from one line taken out of context?

Direct Answer Bercot’s reading confronts the trope that Jesus was “revolutionary” simply for speaking to a woman by showing the text itself explains the real issue: Jews’ hostility toward Samaritans. It warns that lifting one line (“they marveled…”) out of context can create an entire doctrine or narrative that the passage does not teach.

Support from Transcript:

  • He calls it “absurd” to claim “Jewish men disdained women and therefore refused to talk to them,” often tied to John 4.
  • He admits the line “They marveled that He talked with a woman” sounds like a gender issue “taken out of context.”
  • But he points to the text’s explicit reason: the woman says, “How is it that you, being a Jew…[ask]…a Samaritan woman? For Jews have no dealings with Samaritans.”
  • He stresses: she did not say “men have no dealings with women,” but Jews with Samaritans.
  • He argues the disciples were surprised Jesus spoke to “a Samaritan woman,” again emphasizing ethnicity.
  • He adds a contextual clue: the woman then spoke freely to “the men” of the city, and they listened—showing “There was no gender barrier.”
Discussion Follow-ups What other doctrines have you seen built on a single phrase without reading the surrounding verses? How can we train ourselves (and our churches) to let the text explain itself before importing a modern storyline?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next