Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 10
David applies the human-spirit/conscience idea to everyday examples (lie detectors, soldiers needing training to kill, most people not stealing, expecting children to behave before being born again) and to Romans 2:14–16 and Cornelius; which of these examples most challenges your current theology of sin and grace, and what concrete changes would it require in parenting, discipleship, and church discipline?
Another way to ask: David uses examples like lie detectors, soldiers being trained to kill, most people not stealing, and expecting kids to behave before being born again, along with Romans 2 and Cornelius. Which example most challenges your view of sin and grace, and what practical changes would it bring to parenting, discipleship, and church discipline?

Direct Answer Bercot’s most concrete challenge is his claim that we rightly expect moral behavior from children and many unbelievers because the human spirit/conscience remains after the fall. If accepted, it would push churches to call both children and adults to real obedience and self-control (not as earning salvation), while still insisting that salvation requires Christ’s blood and the new birth.

Support from Transcript:

  • Lie detectors: he argues they work because “it is not normal and natural to lie,” since “our spirit inside of us…resist[s]” lying.
  • Soldiers: the army must “train soldiers to kill” because it’s “not natural for humans to kill,” and some refuse to fire.
  • Theft/lawfulness: most people don’t steal even with opportunity; “This spirit inside of us is why most people are peaceful, law-abiding citizens.”
  • Children: “we can and we do expect them…to be kind…good…self-control…love God,” even “before they are born again.”
  • Romans 2:14–16: Gentiles “by nature do the things in the law,” showing “the work of the law written in their hearts,” with “their conscience…bearing witness.”
  • Cornelius illustrates the same: real piety and generosity pre–Holy Spirit, but still needing gospel, then Spirit baptism and water baptism.
Discussion Follow-ups If you take Bercot seriously, how would you adjust parenting from “they can’t help it” to training the will to follow conscience? In discipleship and discipline, how would you address “works of the flesh” in believers while keeping grace central and avoiding a works-salvation message?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done