Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
Bercot criticizes evangelical Protestants for keeping some early customs, rejecting others without a clear pattern, and then adding newer traditions such as Christmas customs with pagan origins. What does this inconsistency reveal about how Christians often decide which traditions feel acceptable?
Another way to ask: Bercot says evangelical Protestants keep some early customs, reject others without a clear reason, and add newer traditions like Christmas customs with pagan roots. What does this show about how Christians often choose which traditions feel acceptable?

Direct Answer

Bercot says this inconsistency shows that Christians often accept or reject traditions without a clear biblical or historical pattern. He argues that Protestants may discard ancient Christian customs while keeping or adding newer customs, even some with pagan origins.

Support from Transcript

- He says most Christians celebrate "Pascha or Easter" and use crosses or the fish symbol. - He says evangelical Protestants are "very inconsistent" about early Christian customs. - He notes they keep some customs, such as Easter and the fish symbol, but ignore others, such as "tracing the sign of the cross on the forehead." - He says there is "no logical pattern" to which traditions have been kept or discarded. - He calls it "ludicrous" that after discarding ancient customs, Christians added traditions not found in Scripture or early writings. - He identifies Christmas as the "paradigm example" and says many Christmas customs are "of pagan origin."

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript implies that preference, habit, or cultural comfort may shape decisions more than Scripture or apostolic testimony.