Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 10
If Bercot is right that the real choice is not “Bible alone” versus “Bible plus tradition,” but “Bible plus apostolic tradition” versus “Bible plus man-made tradition,” what concrete changes might a church or family need to make in its teaching, worship, habits, and decision-making?
Another way to ask: Bercot says the real choice is not “Bible alone” or “Bible plus tradition,” but “Bible plus apostolic tradition” or “Bible plus man-made tradition.” If this is true, what real changes might a church or family need to make in its teaching, worship, habits, and decisions?

Direct Answer

A church or family would need to identify its inherited traditions, test whether they confirm or invalidate Scripture, and give serious attention to early Christian testimony. They might reconsider practices involving baptism, communion, worship meetings, prayer, fasting, Christian customs, and holidays.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot says the real issue is "the Bible plus apostolic tradition" versus "the Bible plus man-made tradition." - He says every Christian already has traditions about baptism, communion, church meetings, and interpretation. - He urges believers to "determine what the traditions of the apostles were and to follow them." - He suggests observing early church customs "unless there is a scriptural reason not to." - He lists customs such as Pascha, fasting Wednesdays and Fridays, set prayer times, the sign of the cross, and Christian symbols. - He criticizes adding customs "neither found in Scripture nor in the early Christian writings," naming Christmas as an example.

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript does not require every listed custom absolutely, but it urges humility, historical inquiry, and consistency when choosing which traditions to practice.