Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 8
Bercot claims a real “kingdom church” thread existed: the kingdom gospel continued for centuries and was obscured especially when the church joined the state under Constantine, yet “kingdom Christians” persisted inside (Francis of Assisi) and outside institutional structures, united mainly by the Apostles’ Creed plus obedience to Jesus; what does this imply about what God prioritizes (precision of distinctive doctrines vs. faithful kingdom living), and where does that collide with your current measure of “true Christianity”?
Another way to ask: If God kept a “kingdom church” going through history, even when the church joined the state, what does that suggest God cares most about—perfect doctrine details or faithful obedience to Jesus? Where does that clash with how you decide what “true Christianity” is?

Direct Answer Bercot implies God’s priority is faithful kingdom living—obedience to Jesus’ teachings “through the grace of God”—more than perfect alignment with later distinctive doctrinal systems. This collides with any measure of “true Christianity” that mainly depends on one group’s unique doctrines and ordinances rather than the shared core of the Apostles’ Creed and kingdom obedience.

Support from Transcript:

  • He says the “kingdom gospel… continued to be preached… for centuries” and “didn’t change until the time of Constantine” when the church joined the state and “had to change the gospel to make that possible.”
  • After Constantine, the institutional church “pretty much dropped the kingdom gospel or… obscured it,” yet “there were always Christians who continued to live it out and to preach it.”
  • He names examples inside/outside: “inside the institutional church, like Francis of Assisi,” and outside in groups like “the Lollards and the Waldensians.”
  • He stresses “no theological uniformity” except “the rather simple Apostles’ Creed,” plus living Jesus’ kingdom teachings by grace.
  • He rejects the denominational version of the pilgrim church: if your marks are “theological doctrines and church ordinances” of your brand, “you’re not going to find any pilgrim church.”
Discussion Follow-ups What do you treat as the non-negotiable markers of Christianity: creed, sacraments/ordinances, or kingdom obedience? How might your evaluation of other believers change if the “kingdom thread” is the main continuity God preserved?