Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
After Grebel’s 1522 change, he wrote, “I don’t even hold my life dear… if only I knew the scripture better,” and he and others interrupted monks publicly for “unscriptural doctrine”; what does this reveal about his view of God, truth, and the value of human life, and how would early Christian expectations about confessing Christ publicly critique the modern preference for private faith and conflict-avoidance?
Another way to ask: What do Grebel’s words and public confrontations show about how he valued truth and even his own life? How might early Christians, who expected public loyalty to Christ, challenge our desire to keep faith private and avoid conflict?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests Grebel valued God’s truth above personal safety and saw public defense of Scripture as worth risking his life, while still feeling accountable to know Scripture rightly. This challenges modern conflict-avoidance by presenting public confession and correction of error as normal fruit of conversion.

Support from Transcript:

  • Dean says Grebel’s conversion is “obvious” and from mid-1522 “it is evident that Grebel was a changed man,” with “laser-sharp purpose.”
  • Grebel’s own words show zeal and risk: “a burning passion… to attack this kind of wolves… I don’t even hold my life dear, if I could get a chance to condemn these men publicly.”
  • He also admits humility and need: “if only I knew the scripture better,” and he asks others to “pray for me.”
  • The Cup and the Cross quote states Grebel and others “interrupted the monks’ sermons when they taught unscriptural doctrine.”
  • Zwingli himself interrupted a friar publicly: “Brother, you are in error there,” showing this public correction was part of their reform culture.
Discussion Follow-ups What kinds of public confession are appropriate today, and what kinds become prideful argument? If Grebel risked his life for truth, what does that say about our fear of social awkwardness or criticism?