Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Radical Reformation History  /  Lecture 4: The Church Councils and the Pilgrim Church  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 1
Dean Taylor quoted Tolstoy’s sarcastic summary of what Constantine was offered: “Christ having died, Constantine could live as he likes… repent and swallow a little bit of bread and some wine.” What picture of God and salvation is being mocked here, and where do you recognize similar “arranged Christianity” temptations in your own church culture?
Another way to ask: What view of God and salvation is Tolstoy making fun of here (live how you want, then repent and take communion)? Where do you see the same “set up” kind of Christianity tempting your church culture?

Direct Answer Based on Dean Taylor’s use of Tolstoy, the mocked picture is a “Christianity” that gives forgiveness and heaven while leaving a person’s power, violence, luxury, and lust untouched—salvation as a transaction that removes embarrassment, not a call into Christ’s kingdom life. Dean suggests the same temptation shows up whenever churches quietly arrange a faith that preserves our old life while still claiming the name “Christian.”

Support from Transcript:

  • Tolstoy’s satire: they didn’t tell Constantine “among you it shall not be so… resist not him that is evil,” but told him he could “continue to be a chieftain and a robber… live in luxury.”
  • “They carefully devised such a Christianity for him as would let him continue to live his old heathen life unembarrassed.”
  • “Christ having died, Constantine could live as he likes… repent and swallow a little bit of bread and some wine.”
  • Dean immediately turns it into a heart-question: “Was that Christianity?… what does it really mean to be a Christian… truly a follower of Christ?”
  • He later warns of communities shifting focus from Christ to easier targets (standards, debates), which can become a new form of “arranged Christianity.”
Discussion Follow-ups Where do we offer people a version of Christianity that costs less than “kingdom life”? What parts of Jesus’ teaching would embarrass our culture if taken literally?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10
Back Questions Next