Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in
Question 2
In the clash between Hans Hut’s urgent missionary drive (“Jesus is coming back…we’ve got to hurry”) and Hubmaier’s move toward “settling down in Nickelsburg and starting the state church,” what do you hear Dean Taylor warning against, and what do you think modern Christians lose when stability and institutional security become the dominant goal?
Another way to ask: In the conflict between Hut’s urgency and Hubmaier’s plan to settle into a state church, what is Dean Taylor warning us about? What do Christians lose when comfort and safety become the main goal?

Direct Answer Dean Taylor warns that stability can become a spiritual distraction when it replaces the urgency of the kingdom and the Great Commission, turning the church inward and comfortable rather than outward and obedient. When institutional security dominates, modern Christians can lose missionary intensity, simplicity, and the willingness to suffer for gospel advance.

Support from Transcript:

  • He contrasts “settling down in Nickelsburg and starting the state church” with Hans Hut’s “Jesus is coming back…we’ve got to hurry to propagate the kingdom.”
  • Taylor frames it as “two worlds clashing,” implying different definitions of church success.
  • He admits Hut had excesses (“a little excessive…putting years and dates”), but still defends the core urgency: “Jesus is going to appear to those who look for his appearing.”
  • Taylor says the Moravian brothers weren’t trying to enjoy community for its own sake: not “kumbaya sessions,” but “there was a purpose.”
  • He quotes Bonhoeffer: “the person who focuses on community will destroy community,” suggesting that community-as-goal can become self-defeating.
  • He ties true church life to mission: “everything in your church was for the propagation…of his kingdom.”
Discussion Follow-ups Where do we measure faithfulness by “settling down” markers (property, programs, safety) rather than by disciple-making? How can stability serve mission without replacing it?