Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Historic Christianity vs Calvinism  /  Lecture 8: Debunking Limited Atonement  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 9
Finny argues Calvinists are forced into either (a) making God’s desire-to-save texts refer only to the elect, or (b) asserting “two wills” in God, with Piper’s line about God being “emotionally complex” and committed to displaying “the full range of His perfections” (including wrath); which option seems more damaging to God’s revealed character, and what does each option train believers to believe about God when they’re suffering, sinning, or evangelizing?
Another way to ask: Which hurts God’s character more: saying God only wants to save the elect, or saying God has “two wills” and is “emotionally complex”? How does each view shape what Christians think about God when they suffer, sin, or share the gospel?

Direct Answer Finny portrays both options as spiritually damaging: (a) narrows God’s benevolence until “all” really means “elect,” and (b) makes God divided—wanting to save all while also choosing wrath to display glory. He suggests both distort God’s character and can shape believers to view God as less loving and less trustworthy in hardship, repentance, and evangelism.

Support from Transcript:

  • Finny says Calvinists must either reinterpret “all/world” as referring to “the elect,” a path “a lot of Calvinists go down.”
  • Or they assert “God has two wills,” which he connects to Piper’s language about God being “emotionally complex.”
  • He summarizes Piper: God wants to save everybody “but he can’t because he wants to manifest his wrath.”
  • He quotes Piper: God’s will to save all is “restrained by… the glorification of the full range of His perfections… in exalting His sovereign grace.”
  • Finny responds: “both horrible, both miserable… Either way… they create an unbiblical and unloving God that drives people away from the Father.”
  • He adds this is part of Satan’s tactic: “to question the character of God… coming from inside the church.”
Discussion Follow-ups When you are battling sin or despair, which picture is more tempting: a God who never intended you, or a God who is ‘complex’ enough to will your ruin for a higher display?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next