Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Historic Christianity vs Calvinism  /  Lecture 10: Implications of Calvinism Today  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 8
Derek Webb describes himself as “in the grave next to Lazarus waiting for my name,” concluding, “maybe it’s all real and I’m just not chosen”; how does that mindset reshape evangelism, repentance, assurance, and the emotional tone of the Christian life—and what would early Christians have assumed a seeker should do instead of “wait”?
Another way to ask: Derek Webb feels like he’s “waiting” to see if he is chosen. How would that way of thinking affect evangelism, repentance, and assurance, and what would early Christians have told a seeker to do instead of just wait?

Direct Answer Finny presents Derek Webb’s mindset as a logical emotional outcome of Calvinism: if faith is a unilateral gift, the seeker becomes passive—“waiting”—and may conclude, “I’m just not chosen,” which erodes assurance and drains urgency from repentance and evangelism. By contrast, Finny earlier describes early Christian practice as holding “repent, believe, be baptized” together, implying a seeker is expected to respond rather than wait.

Support from Transcript:

  • Derek Webb: “I’m literally in the grave next to Lazarus waiting for my name… I won’t be able to resist it… I cannot coax him over.”
  • He concludes: “Maybe God made me a… vessel for destruction… maybe it’s all real and I’m just not chosen.”
  • Finny links this to Calvinism’s themes: “Lazarus dead, vessels of destruction, Romans 9… all the same things we’ve been talking about.”
  • Finny frames the practical effect: it shows why this theology “impedes the character of God” and turns people away.
  • Early church pattern (Finny’s history section): baptism was tied to response—“repent, believe, be baptized… They held all three together.”
  • The implied contrast is action vs passivity: early Christians saw baptism within a repentance-faith response, not mere waiting.
Discussion Follow-ups How does the ‘waiting for my name’ posture affect motivation to seek God, confess sin, or ask for help? What pastoral counsel would you give a person trapped in passivity and fatalism?

Jumpstarter 8 of 10
Back Questions Next