Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Change of Allegiance  /  Yahweh is a Warrior  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 9
Dean quotes Canon 12 of Nicaea (325) treating Christians who returned to the military as needing years of repentance before communion; what assumptions about baptism, discipleship, and church discipline are exposed by that canon, and what would have to change in your church for that kind of seriousness to be even thinkable?
Another way to ask: Nicaea’s Canon 12 says soldiers who came back to the military needed years of repentance before communion. What does that show about how serious the early church was about baptism, discipleship, and discipline, and what would your church need to change to take it that seriously?

Direct Answer Canon 12 assumes baptismal grace demands a visible change of life, that military service contradicts Christian discipleship, and that the church must enforce discipline with long, concrete repentance before full fellowship.

Support from Transcript:

  • Dean quotes the canon describing those “called by grace” who “threw away their military uniforms,” implying conversion/disciple-zeal included leaving the military.
  • Returning to the military is condemned sharply: “then later returned like dogs to their own vomit,” showing it’s treated as serious moral backsliding.
  • The discipline is concrete and lengthy: “three years as hearers and ten years as prostrators,” before restoration to communion.
  • The canon requires observable repentance: “give evidence of their conversions by their actions and not just mere pretense with fear, tears… and good works.”
  • Dean emphasizes the significance: even while church/state ties were forming, the council still had “laws that it is wrong for Christians to participate in the military.”
Discussion Follow-ups Dean doesn’t map out modern steps, but the transcript implies churches would need a stronger view of membership, repentance, and accountability—where actions (not just words) determine readiness for communion.

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next