Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Discussion Jumpstarter

Study leader reference - not a definitive answer
Hope For Wondering Amish / I left The Old Order Mennonites ~Jerry Martin
Watch Full Video
Question 9
Jerry said his house-church season was sweetest when there was “a lot of prayer and confession,” but later offense and disagreement led to “empty fellowship,” and he claimed the leader’s heart condition affected whether Scripture had “authority” or “fell to the ground”; what does that suggest about how God relates to gatherings, and how does it confront the modern assumption that correct teaching alone guarantees spiritual power?
Another way to ask: Jerry said his group felt alive when there was prayer and confession, but later it became empty, and the leader’s heart affected how God’s Word landed. What does that suggest about what God cares about in a church gathering, and why isn’t correct teaching by itself enough to bring real spiritual power?
Discussion Jumpstarter

Direct Answer
Jerry’s story suggests God’s presence in gatherings is closely tied to the heart condition of the people—especially leaders—so that offense and closed hearts can drain meetings of spiritual life even if Scripture is read. This confronts the assumption that correct words or teaching techniques automatically produce “authority”; Jerry argues authority flows from a clear heart and God behind the words.

Support from Transcript:
  • He describes the sweetest season: “a lot of prayer and confession… everybody had a voice… God gave them fresh revelation.”
  • Visitors sensed something real: strangers said “there’s just a sense of love here.”
  • Later, disagreements and worship-style differences led to being “offended,” and “people started walking off instead of coming in.”
  • He says leadership mattered: if the leader had a “clear heart,” there was “daily bread,” but if the leader walked “in offense,” the Scripture “fell to the ground.”
  • He illustrates with Jesus’ sermon: people heard Isaiah “time and again… just words,” but Jesus taught “with authority,” because “something behind it.”
  • He personalizes it: if his heart isn’t clear, his words feel like they “hit the ceiling” or fall empty.
Discussion Follow-ups How should a church handle offense quickly so fellowship doesn’t become “empty”? What practices (confession, prayer, humility) protect the “authority” of God’s Word among a people?
Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Previous All Questions Next