Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Discussion Jumpstarter

Study leader reference - not a definitive answer
Anabaptist Perspectives / I Was a Muslim in the Middle East. This Is Why I Left Islam - John Ghanim
Watch Full Video
Question 5
In the refugee journey (Iran ? Turkey border, arrests, beatings, “I was crying, ‘Where are you, God?’”), what does his experience suggest about God’s presence in suffering, and how should Christians talk about providence without turning hardship into either cynicism (“God isn’t there”) or clichés (“everything is easy when God leads”)?
Another way to ask: When he suffered on the refugee journey and cried, "Where are you, God?" what might that teach us about God being present in suffering? How can Christians talk about God’s guidance without saying either “God isn’t there” or “following God is always easy”?
Discussion Jumpstarter

Direct Answer
The transcript shows that suffering didn’t feel like God was absent—he cried out to God precisely because he still hoped God was there—but the journey was not “easy.” Christians should speak about providence in a way that allows honest lament and real danger, while still trusting God can meet and lead a person through it.

Support from Transcript:
  • He faced repeated trauma: “I was arrested three times. I was beaten by the police… sent me back many times.”
  • His response was raw prayer, not polished confidence: “It was midnight… I was crying. Where are you, God? Where are you, God?”
  • He felt close to death: “I saw death in front of my eyes.”
  • The hardship continued even after arrival: “Life wasn’t easy… I was homeless, basically… very cold… I built my own small tent.”
  • Yet later he interprets timing as meaningful: “I believe God sent them in the right time… God sent them.”
  • He testifies to real spiritual change later, not immediate comfort: after faith, “I felt… a new creation… hungry… desire to read the Bible.”
Discussion Follow-ups How can churches make space for people to say “Where are you, God?” without treating it as unbelief, while still encouraging perseverance?
Jumpstarter 5 of 10
Previous All Questions Next