Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Lying "for good"--Rahab as justification for Christian's right to lie in difficult circumstances?

Started by Java Bradley
October 31, 2026
6 replies
79 views
#1
Hi everyone! God bless you. I'm part of a bible study with several visitors who think differently on the topic of lying. We recently discussed Jesus' teaching on swearing oaths and the topic of honesty came up. The perspective one of the visitors defended was that the Christian standard should always be to tell the truth, but there are occasions when/where lies can be the better option. Rahab deceiving her king to hide the Israelite messengers was one example, and Corrie Ten Boom's family's incredible efforts to protect Jews during the holocaust by hiding them and lying about it was another. My own take was that Rahab was praised because she hid the spies, not because she used lying or deceit to do so. I also felt that, like Rahab, Corrie Ten Boom's family's efforts are to be commended, but this doesn't mean every choice they made along the way was justified by the teachings of Jesus. Some would argue honesty would have jeopardized the lives of the Israelite spies and the persecuted Jews, and this isn't a small matter. But, I argued lying/deceiving and telling everything you know about the people you're trying to protect, aren't the only options available to us. Jesus remained silent before His accusers. This is another option for us too. Or, maybe there are other options as well: fleeing, hiding, remaining silent, avoiding the authorities as much as possible, and maybe other options? Would love to hear any thoughts you might have in order to better understand this topic, and improve my ability to help others do the same. Also, would love additional scripture references and maybe other stories about faithfulness in this area of life in the lives of Christians throughout history. Thank you!

Replies (6)

#2
Hi Java, My mind goes to David the king of Israel. He told many lies, as he was being chased after by Saul. Yet God highly regarded David. It was for the Sake of David life, that God kept his descendants upon the throne for generations to come. I feel at time there could have been better options. Perhaps instead of seeking help from the priests and asking for a sword and bread, and telling (lying to) the priest that he was on a special mission, he could have asked God to send him bread from heaven. Later David himself greatly regretted his actions. Yet I do not remember reading anywhere where God himself ever condemned David, except for his affair with Bathsheba and when he numbered the people without giving a ransom. Concerning the above mentioned account of him seeking help from the priest, Jesus himself referenced the account and chose not to condemn David. I am sorry I have not included scripture references above. I also will say I completely agree with you concerning, refraining from speaking falsehood. I must say though I do not understand how God views every falsehood which has been spoken. Yes, I am confused myself
#3
I guess I shall also say, in no way shape or form am I trying to condone Rahab, Corrie Ten Boom, or David I believe God made it clear in the Old Testament, that he hates lying lips. I am only trying to understand the Mind of God. I am confused. Enlighten my eyes.
#4
I guess I will share one more thought. Jesus talked a lot about prayer. He told his disciples ask him for miracles. He said mountains can be moved and cast into the sea if we have faith. Throughout the book of Acts I can not think of a single place where the Apostles ever told a lie. Yet they lived in great danger. I personally feel that God would much rather us ask him to do a divine miracle on our behalf, rather than for us to stoop down to lying and or self-defense. God can do anything. He is perfectly capable of protecting us and providing for our needs. We just need to ask him for help. I welcome your feedback. God bless you all.
#5
Why is a lie evil?

That is something I have considered.

A lie misrepresents reality to someone and it’s far more difficult to make sound decisions, or even sound thinking, when the framework we are working within is not reality.

Truth = As things actually are.

Rahab is certainly an exception and it would appear God overlooked her lie in lue of the overall situation.
#6
I don't think we can compare the lying in the Old Testament with our mission in the New covenant. In the OT the people of God acted in ways to preserve themselves and their nation, but it is not so in the covenant. In the new covenant we are not to resist enemies, not to seek self preservation, but to overcome evil with good. This is why I think lying has lost it's place entirely. Also, we are sheep for the slaughter, often in a position to give up our rights and even our lives for the sake of the gospel. We are to be innocent as doves, lambs in the midst of wolves, light of the world, salt of the earth, etc.

Join the Conversation

Create a free account or log in to post and reply.

Confirm Delete

Are you sure you want to delete this post? This action cannot be undone.