Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Gossip.

Started by Micah Miller
December 30, 2025
4 replies
769 views
#1

I just listened to David Bercot's message entitled "Gossip-Not a Minor Sin." This is a convicting message and I encourage everyone to listen to it under the course "Radical Christian Living." It left me with practical ways of overcoming this problem. However, I wondered if this could be taken too far. Are there times when one should talk with others about the struggles of others? I have wrestled with this question as a schoolteacher.

Sometimes I feel I should tell somebody else (a board member) about what is going on in my classroom. When we have teacher meetings, it's great if you can share the struggles of one of your students to get advice and other perspectives on how to handle the situation. I typically don't ask myself, "Would my student want me to relate this information to the school board?" before I tell them about it.

Here's another scenario: I may be having severe struggles with a certain individual. Let's assume this would fall into a Matthew 7 category, where it is a speck in that person's eye that I must simply overlook. Is there never a time for me to talk to my parents about this situation. I might say things about that person that he might not want me to say, but if I would not, there would be little if any context for what I am saying to my parents.

What about when I am genuinely concerned about something another brother may be teaching? Should I not say anything about it to anyone else?

Just some of the musings of my head. Any comments?

Replies (4)

#2

Good question, Micah. I believe there's definitely a place to talk to someone about concerns like this. In cases like this, I try to ensure that I

  • am bringing up the issue out of a genuine desire to help someone.
  • am only sharing the information I need to share and with the people I need to share it with.
  • don't share information with someone that I suspect will then share it with more people without sticking to these principles.
  • try to frame negative things in as positive and understanding light as I possibly can, so that people don't get an overly negative view of the person I'm discussing.
#3

Thank you Lynn for the feedback. That advice seems sound to me. I will go over that checklist in the future when needed.

#4

This is a topic that I struggle with, and I always feel guilty afterward! I, too, struggle to know when it may be appropriate to speak with others about a situation versus simply being gossip. I agree with the other response - I think that our heart matters a lot in the situation - are we speaking to help or speaking to have fun...

#5
Micah, I had same feeling that brother Bercot went too far with the gossip definition and examples he gave in his book. For me personally, we should never enjoy speaking bad about others and we should never speak something false about others. The dangerous sin is malicious gossip, speaking things that are not true about someone that is intended to damage their reputation, this indeed we must watch out for. 

Join the Conversation

Create a free account or log in to post and reply.

Confirm Delete

Are you sure you want to delete this post? This action cannot be undone.