Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 4
He describes theologians as people who “read their own concept of Christianity back into the Scriptures” and therefore turn even John’s writing into a treatise; where do you feel most tempted to treat the New Testament as a system to master rather than a kingdom life to enter, and what does that temptation reveal about what you want from Christianity?
Another way to ask: Where are you most tempted to treat the New Testament like a system to figure out instead of a way of life to follow? What does that say about what you want Christianity to give you?

Direct Answer The transcript points to a temptation to approach the New Testament mainly as material for building a theological system; that temptation often reveals a desire for mastery, control, or status (“wise and prudent”) rather than simple obedience to the kingdom life Jesus taught.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot says theologians “read their own concept of Christianity back into the Scriptures.”
  • Because they thought theology is Christianity’s essence, “they turned Paul into a theologian like themselves.”
  • He says this also affects reading John: “Even the writings of… the Apostle John, become theological treatises.”
  • He connects the issue to pride in expertise by raising Jesus’ saying about God hiding things “from the wise and prudent” and revealing them “to babes.”
  • He contrasts this with Jesus’ focus: “the kingdom and living the kingdom life.”
Discussion Follow-ups In what ways might “system mastering” be an attempt to feel secure without the hard work of actually living the kingdom (relationships, integrity, sexual purity, truthfulness, etc.)?