Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 3 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Will the Theologians Please Sit Down  /  Chapter 23: Clueless about Historic Christianity  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 3
Bercot argues that many believers imagine the apostle John would feel at home in a conservative church today but out of place with Ignatius or Polycarp; what does that assumption reveal about how we locate authority—Scripture alone as text, Scripture as historically received, or trusted modern interpreters—and where do you see yourself defaulting?
Another way to ask: If someone thinks the apostle John would fit in better with a conservative church today than with Ignatius or Polycarp, what does that say about where they look for authority? Where do you tend to look first—just the Bible text, the Bible as the early church understood it, or modern teachers?

Direct Answer Bercot suggests this assumption reveals that many Christians functionally trust modern interpretations (including claims about Greek and theology) more than the way Scripture was received and lived immediately after the apostles. The transcript pushes readers to test their “Scripture alone” instincts by actually comparing modern theology with the earliest Christian witnesses.

Support from Transcript:

  • He says people imagine John would feel “totally out of place” in second-century churches led by men “whom he had personally discipled,” yet “right at home” in conservative churches today.
  • He includes interpretive authority: moderns assume today’s theologians understand “Koine Greek exactly the way he did.”
  • Bercot calls this fantasy: “If you think that’s the reality…dream on.”
  • He grounds authority in early evidence: “we still have the writings of the early Christians…we can read their writings for ourselves.”
  • He highlights continuity: second-century Christians said they were “holding fast to what the apostles had taught them,” not creating a new system.
Discussion Follow-ups When you interpret a hard passage in Paul, do you instinctively reach for modern theologians first, or for how early Christians read the same texts?

Jumpstarter 3 of 10
Back Questions Next