Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
Using his coffee analogy, Bercot says cosmetics become a “trap” that resets what men view as normal beauty and can even harm marriages because husbands fall in love with an “artificial face”; what parts of that argument seem persuasive or unfair, and how should engaged or married couples pursue honesty and attraction without manipulation?
Another way to ask: Bercot says makeup can change what men think “normal” beauty is and can hurt marriages because a husband may fall for a face that isn’t real. What seems fair or unfair in that argument, and how can couples be honest and still stay attracted without trying to trick each other?

Direct Answer Bercot’s argument is persuasive in showing how a “new normal” can form: once makeup is common, women feel forced to wear it just to be seen as attractive, and that can create disappointment and comparison in marriage. The transcript doesn’t address every nuance (like minimal makeup or cultural differences), but it urges couples toward honesty—being known as you really are—and toward prioritizing character over sensual appeal.

Support from Transcript:

  • Coffee analogy: the body adjusts so you need more to get the same effect; “you’ve gained nothing,” and eventually you need coffee just to reach your old baseline.
  • He applies it: as cosmetics spread, men “got used to the look,” so women without cosmetics appear “drab,” yet women are “no more beautiful… than… when none… wore makeup.”
  • He says after being away from makeup, painted faces look “garish,” and he prefers “the natural look.”
  • Marriage concern: husbands may fall in love with an “artificial face,” then after marriage “discovers what his wife really looks like,” leading to “unpleasant surprises.”
  • He adds workplace comparison: husbands see other women always with makeup but see their wives often without, which “does not enhance a marriage.”
  • He advises not to “run ahead of your spouse” and to focus first on “the hidden person of the heart… gentle and quiet spirit.”
Discussion Follow-ups What does “honesty” look like during courtship—should a couple intentionally see each other in ordinary, unenhanced settings? How can spouses nurture attraction through kindness, gentleness, and faithfulness rather than through image-management?