Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
Origen says Christ “remains silent” against accusations and places His defense in the lives of His disciples; if that is true, what specific accusations about Jesus or Christianity in your context are being “answered” (or reinforced) by the actual conduct of Christians you know—including you?
Another way to ask: Origen says Jesus’ defense against accusations is seen in how His followers live. What complaints people have about Jesus or Christianity where you live are being answered—or made worse—by the way Christians (including you) act?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests accusations are answered when Christians visibly live in love, fidelity, truthfulness, and non-retaliation—and they are reinforced when Christian conduct looks no different from the surrounding world, especially in cruelty, dishonesty, or lack of love.

Support from Transcript:

  • Origen: Christ “continues silent before these charges” and “places His defense in the lives of His genuine disciples who are a preeminent testimony.”
  • He connects this to Jesus’ own example: His “life and conduct” was a better refutation than arguments.
  • Athenagoras gives practical defenses: not striking back, not suing when robbed, generosity, loving neighbors.
  • Tertullian says outsiders remarked, “See how they love one another,” implying love is a public apologetic.
  • Tertullian argues Christians weren’t found in court lists for crimes; if true, that answers claims that Christianity breeds evil.
  • He also notes pagans used Christians as a moral comparison: “Why is someone so deceitful when Christians are so self-denying?” implying hypocrisy weakens Christ’s “defense.”
Discussion Follow-ups In your setting, what are the loudest charges—hypocrisy, harm, greed, political manipulation? What concrete behaviors would make those charges less believable?