Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 5

Justin Martyr said he concluded Christianity couldn’t be a religion of “wickedness and pleasure” because Christians were “fearless in death”; what aspects of our own lives would have to change for unbelievers to reason about us the same way—without relying on our words?

Another way to ask: Justin Martyr thought Christians couldn’t be living for “wickedness and pleasure” because they faced death without fear. What would need to change in our lives so nonbelievers could see that kind of faith in us without us explaining it?

Direct Answer From the transcript, unbelievers would need to see a visible holiness and costly faithfulness—especially courage under loss and suffering, plus a consistent lifestyle of love and non-retaliation—so that our lives “refute” accusations without speeches.

Support from Transcript:

Justin: Christians were “fearless in death,” and he reasoned they couldn’t be living for “wickedness and pleasure,” since a pleasure-seeker would not “welcome death.”
Bercot links this to public martyrdom: Christians refused to renounce Christ even when tortured.
Athenagoras describes deeds over words: “They don’t rehearse speeches…When struck, they don’t strike back…When robbed, they don’t go to law…They give…love their neighbors.”
Tertullian emphasizes integrity toward all: forbidden to “wish ill…do ill…speak ill, or even…think ill of any person.”
Tertullian notes outsiders said, “See how they love one another,” and even pagans recognized the Christian as “noted for his fidelity.”
Origen: Christ’s defense is “in the lives of His genuine disciples.”

Discussion Follow-ups What “pleasure” or “self-protection” habits in our culture most undermine the kind of credibility Justin described?

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 5 of 10