Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 3 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
The Kingdom that Turned the World Upside Down  /  Chapter 30, The Alternate Stream  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 3
Bercot ties rejection of nonresistance to acceptance of church-state union, saying this led to approving “war, capital punishments, and torture”; what beliefs about God’s justice and God’s mercy have to shift in order for Christians to bless these practices, and what New Testament teachings does the chapter imply are being sidelined?
Another way to ask: What would Christians have to believe about God’s justice and mercy to support war, executions, and torture? Which New Testament teachings does the chapter suggest get pushed aside when they do that?

Direct Answer Bercot’s argument implies Christians bless war and coercive punishments when they shift from Jesus’ “law of grace” and mercy to a framework where the sword is seen as necessary and acceptable for Christians because the state and Church are united. That move sidelines Jesus’ enemy-love and non-killing teachings.

Support from Transcript:

  • He says because Augustinian reformers accepted church-state union, they “did not object to use of the sword.”
  • They believed “the sword was necessary for the operation and preservation of the states,” and since the state is joined to the Church, Christians could participate in “war, capital punishments, and torture.”
  • The Lollards (moving toward Kingdom teaching) directly contrast this with the New Testament: war is “expressly contrary to the New Testament… the law of grace and full of mercies.”
  • They appeal to Jesus’ teaching: Christ “specially taught a man to love his enemies… and not to slay them.”
  • They quote Jesus’ warning: “He who smites with the sword shall perish by the sword,” and connect violence with loss of love.
Discussion Follow-ups The transcript frames this as a kingdom-methods issue: do we see God’s justice mainly expressed through coercive force, or through Jesus’ mercy-shaped commands to His disciples?

Jumpstarter 3 of 10
Back Questions Next