Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
The Kingdom that Turned the World Upside Down  /  Chapter 15, Has Anyone Done This in Real Life  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 2
The chapter describes Jewish expectations that the Messiah would lead a war of liberation like the Maccabees did; how does Jesus’ refusal to play that role redefine what God’s salvation looks like, and what kinds of “Messiah expectations” do Christians today still carry that the chapter implicitly confronts?
Another way to ask: Many Jews expected the Messiah to start a freedom war like the Maccabees; how does Jesus refusing that role change what we think salvation is? What “Messiah” hopes do Christians today still have that this chapter challenges?

Direct Answer The transcript presents Jesus’ refusal to lead a liberation war as a redefinition of salvation away from national independence and toward allegiance to God’s kingdom, where earthly power struggles are “irrelevant.” Implicitly, it confronts any Christian expectation that God’s deliverance mainly looks like winning political control or restoring a nation’s freedom.

Support from Transcript:

  • The Jews “firmly believed” Messiah would lead a “victorious war of liberation against Rome,” reasoning: if Maccabees overthrew Greeks, “how much more so would the Messiah overthrow the Romans?”
  • Jesus instead teaches enemy-love, second-mile service, and tax payment—actions that undermined revolutionary hopes.
  • Bercot explains why: Jesus was “a soldier here on earth,” but “his citizenship was in God’s kingdom.”
  • “God’s kingdom rendered Jewish national affairs irrelevant,” and “Struggles for earthly power and earthly independence are meaningless in the realm of eternity.”
  • The disciples also “ignored the Jewish fight for freedom,” and Acts/Epistles don’t even mention it—showing how the church’s mission wasn’t national liberation.
Discussion Follow-ups Where are we tempted to measure God’s faithfulness by national outcomes? How might the church’s mission look different if we treated political wins as spiritually irrelevant the way the chapter suggests?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next